Godwin value??

[Benflicky]

I got this offer. Godwin and Gallup for Baldwin. Two young players with potential for Baldwin. Any thoughts?

[Mjvb5]

Id prefer baldwin as long as this injurty doesnt become soemting big

[Space Cowboy]

30 with bad knees? I'd go for the pair and the youth.

[tom14cat14]

Godwin and Gallup for me. I do think Baldwin will have a big year. But over the next 3 years I think Godwin will be better and Gallup has a chance to be solid starter.

[Indy Blue]

Pretty simple for me. If you are a win now contender you stick with with Baldwin. If not, take the two younger WRs who both have a lot of upside.

[topher]

I think Baldwin is worth more than this.

[zoster80]

Pretty simple for me. If you are a win now contender you stick with with Baldwin. If not, take the two younger WRs who both have a lot of upside.

It's not as simple I do think that if you are contending you go Baldwin, but your not you should be able to net a bit more than this...lots of upside there, but Baldwin is tied to the best QB in the league, that is worth something too, I'd want a bit more.

[Bot101]

Pretty simple for me. If you are a win now contender you stick with with Baldwin. If not, take the two younger WRs who both have a lot of upside.

It's not as simple I do think that if you are contending you go Baldwin, but your not you should be able to net a bit more than this...lots of upside there, but Baldwin is tied to the best QB in the league, that is worth something too, I'd want a bit more.

Best QB in the league. Lol.

Im making this trade. Baldwin is on the decline and Godwin and Gallup are ascending, or potentially ascending. I paid a 2019 1st for Godwin. So I am very high on him.

[zoster80]

Pretty simple for me. If you are a win now contender you stick with with Baldwin. If not, take the two younger WRs who both have a lot of upside.

It's not as simple I do think that if you are contending you go Baldwin, but your not you should be able to net a bit more than this...lots of upside there, but Baldwin is tied to the best QB in the league, that is worth something too, I'd want a bit more.

Best QB in the league. Lol.

Im making this trade. Baldwin is on the decline and Godwin and Gallup are ascending, or potentially ascending. I paid a 2019 1st for Godwin. So I am very high on him.

I don't disagree with your assessment of those guys, I own Godwin too although he fell to early 3rd for me, they are accending not doubt, but they have roadblocks, Godwins will have a tough time getting the target share Baldwin gets and Gallup is tied to Dak, who I think is a care taker type which I don't like at all...

as far as laughing about Wilson, being the best...how far do you think he is? He scored most points in my league last year, he's only 30, and has been consistently top 5 for years...I love Rodgers as I own him too, but he's like 5 years older I know he has less mileage due to being behind Farve at the beginning of his career, I don't think there anyone else I would consider as a top asset. Brady, Brees, Newton, Watson even Luck could be number one this coming year, but as far as top asset, I think the convo ends with Wilson and Rodgers....sorry about the hijack.

[shaggz_]

go for the youth

[jwb32]

With Baldwin's recent health issues, this is a solid return for a rebuild.

[Goddard]

Pretty simple for me. If you are a win now contender you stick with with Baldwin. If not, take the two younger WRs who both have a lot of upside.

I agree. I like Baldwin, but I just don't see anyone offering more than that for him right now.

[notweswelker]

30 with bad knees? I'd go for the pair and the youth.

Yeah how I feel too. Baldwin might hurt you this year but I like potential at this point.