Rookie Draft Results

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

For anyone interested in following along, here's the rookie draft so far for my team in sig.

EDIT: Updated through 3.05. Also, considering offering the 3.07 for Ryan Grant? Or which rookie should I take there?

1.01 Saquon Barkley
1.02 Derrius Guice
1.03 Sony Michel
1.04 Rashaad Penny
1.05 Nick Chubb
1.06 Royce Freeman
1.07 Ronald Jones
1.08 Kerryon Johnson
1.09 Calvin Ridley
1.10 D.J. Moore
1.11 Christian Kirk
1.12 Anthony Miller
2.01 Courtland Sutton
2.02 George Kittle (me - traded Drew Brees + Jack Doyle for 2.02)
2.03 Michael Gallup
2.04 Mike Gesicki
2.05 Nyheim Hines
2.06 Jordan Wilkins
2.07 James Washington
2.08 Lamar Jackson
2.09 Hayden Hurst
2.10 Dante Pettis (me - traded Julio Jones for Christian McCaffrey + 2.10 + 3.11)
2.11 Baker Mayfield
2.12 Tre'Quan Smith
3.01 Kalen Ballage
3.02 Antonio Callaway
3.03 Dallas Goedert (me)
3.04 Josh Rosen
3.05 Sam Darnold (me - traded Spencer Ware + 3.11 for 3.05 + 3.07)

[jcc6fd]

Think you gave up too much for Kittle. The Julio trade is probably fair value but ultimately not one I would have made. I'd be looking to take Darnold or Rosen at 3.03. Could be your Brady replacement and anytime you can get a first round talent in the 3rd, regardless of position, I'm a fan.

[Cowboysfan33]

For anyone interested in following along, here's the rookie draft so far for my team in sig. I'm open to hearing your thoughts on how it's gone so far as well as input on who to take at 3.03 and 3.11.

1.01 Saquon Barkley
1.02 Derrius Guice
1.03 Sony Michel
1.04 Rashaad Penny
1.05 Nick Chubb
1.06 Royce Freeman
1.07 Ronald Jones
1.08 Kerryon Johnson
1.09 Calvin Ridley
1.10 D.J. Moore
1.11 Christian Kirk
1.12 Anthony Miller
2.01 Courtland Sutton
2.02 George Kittle (me - traded Drew Brees + Jack Doyle for 2.02)
2.03 Michael Gallup
2.04 Mike Gesicki
2.05 Nyheim Hines
2.06 Jordan Wilkins
2.07 James Washington
2.08 Lamar Jackson
2.09 Hayden Hurst
2.10 Dante Pettis (me - traded Julio Jones for Christian McCaffrey + 2.10 + 3.11)
2.11 Baker Mayfield

I’m surprised that Sutton fell to 2.01, especially with all of the training camp buzz. Also, I’m surprised that K.Ballage hasn’t been selected yet.

[Goddard]

Julio trade isn't bad, as long as Kupp, Sadners, or Jordy can put up WR3 numbers.

[hudini33]

For anyone interested in following along, here's the rookie draft so far for my team in sig. I'm open to hearing your thoughts on how it's gone so far as well as input on who to take at 3.03 and 3.11.

1.01 Saquon Barkley
1.02 Derrius Guice
1.03 Sony Michel
1.04 Rashaad Penny
1.05 Nick Chubb
1.06 Royce Freeman
1.07 Ronald Jones
1.08 Kerryon Johnson
1.09 Calvin Ridley
1.10 D.J. Moore
1.11 Christian Kirk
1.12 Anthony Miller
2.01 Courtland Sutton
2.02 George Kittle (me - traded Drew Brees + Jack Doyle for 2.02)
2.03 Michael Gallup
2.04 Mike Gesicki
2.05 Nyheim Hines
2.06 Jordan Wilkins
2.07 James Washington
2.08 Lamar Jackson
2.09 Hayden Hurst
2.10 Dante Pettis (me - traded Julio Jones for Christian McCaffrey + 2.10 + 3.11)
2.11 Baker Mayfield

I’m surprised that Sutton fell to 2.01, especially with all of the training camp buzz. Also, I’m surprised that K.Ballage hasn’t been selected yet.

Exactly my thoughts. I would much rather have Sutton than Kirk.

[bjd5211]

Ya, I think the 8 RBs, DJ and Sutton are the clear top 10 at this point.

[esloan35]

Last 10 days have shuffled things around a bit. Still early with more changes to come I'm sure.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Think you gave up too much for Kittle. The Julio trade is probably fair value but ultimately not one I would have made. I'd be looking to take Darnold or Rosen at 3.03. Could be your Brady replacement and anytime you can get a first round talent in the 3rd, regardless of position, I'm a fan.

Not really a fan of Darnold or Rosen. Thoughts on Goedert or Coutee instead if they're still available at 3.03?

I’m surprised that Sutton fell to 2.01, especially with all of the training camp buzz. Also, I’m surprised that K.Ballage hasn’t been selected yet.

I'd expect Ballage to be taken in the next couple of picks, otherwise I'll happily draft him at 3.03.

[bjd5211]

I love Goedert, he was an early 2 for me until the NFL Draft, landing spot tanked him a bit. Sounds like he will be very involved in the offense though, especially in the redzone, and he looked great last night. Definitely in on him late 2 or later.

[BigBawseRoss]

that kittle trade is baffling to say the least.

even if you dont like darnold or rosen they are the right pick there and they can be flipped for a 2nd down the road if needed.

[jcc6fd]

Think you gave up too much for Kittle. The Julio trade is probably fair value but ultimately not one I would have made. I'd be looking to take Darnold or Rosen at 3.03. Could be your Brady replacement and anytime you can get a first round talent in the 3rd, regardless of position, I'm a fan.

Not really a fan of Darnold or Rosen. Thoughts on Goedert or Coutee instead if they're still available at 3.03

My top recommendation is still the QBs but if they’re a pass for you then Goedert or Ballage are the players I’d be considering. Don’t really understand the appeal of Coutee

[vixen]

Not really a fan of Darnold or Rosen. Thoughts on Goedert or Coutee instead if they're still available at 3.03

My top recommendation is still the QBs but if they’re a pass for you then Goedert or Ballage are the players I’d be considering. Don’t really understand the appeal of Coutee

i agree

[Kkiddynamite]

I like both the QBs and outside of Baker they are the next best imo. Not a fan of either trades tbh but Id go QB/Goedert/Ballage. I like Keke and if not for the injury he would have opened the season as the starting slot WR and he will eventually take the job.

The first trade really baffles me as Id rather have Doyle than Kittle, but I guess if hes your guy...

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I took Goedert at 3.03 but traded back into the 3rd to grab Darnold as well.

What should I do with the 3.07? I'm thinking about offering it up for Ryan Grant, but I'm also considering KeKe Coutee and DJ Chark at that pick.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Any input on who to take at 3.07?