How far off is this...TRADE COMPLETE

[EAGLES]

How far apart is this trade...

For team in sig. Not sure why, but I have a gut feeling about Penny. I think he’s an upgrade over Tevin (although I have held Tevin for a while now and have his value not too far from Penny). I’d be using Mack here while he still has value. I’d then try to get Wilkins off waivers.

Or I could keep Julio and just target Penny

Team A gives:
Julio, Tevin Coleman, Mack, 2019 1st

Team B gives:
AB, Penny

Final trade:
Gave: Julio, Mack, Tevin & 2019 2nd
Received: AB & Penny

[kaius]

I’ll take the Julio side.

[vixen]

i would say it is close...i think i would also take the Julio side. but i love me some Antonio, so if you ask me tomorrow, i might take that side

[BigBawseRoss]

Wow I think this is AB side pretty easily. So based on these results it’s not far off

[sloth8u]

id rather the ab side, i just think he's the best player in the deal by a good margin. i would not trade penny for coleman, mack, future 1....so i would easily take the brown/penny end of this deal.

[EAGLES]

^^^bump^^^
Any other opinions?

[playa_hata]

id take the ab side

[FantasyFreak]

AB side for me.

[Pet_Smith]

Julio side. He and AB are a scratch for me. Coleman is worth a late first, Mack an early second/late first, and then there's a 2019 1st - for me, the sheer weight in numbers of 1st takes it over Penny as he as yet has done nothing on an NFL field.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I'd prefer the Brown side, but it's a fair offer.

[Goddard]

I'd much rather have AB over Julio, but I like both. I'd see if there's anyway you can swap that 2019 1st with a 2nd.

[EAGLES]

I'd much rather have AB over Julio, but I like both. I'd see if there's anyway you can swap that 2019 1st with a 2nd.

I actually was able to change the 1st to a 2nd.

Final trade:
Gave: Julio, Mack, Tevin & 2019 2nd
Received: AB & Penny

[darewood11]

Julio side. He and AB are a scratch for me. Coleman is worth a late first, Mack an early second/late first, and then there's a 2019 1st - for me, the sheer weight in numbers of 1st takes it over Penny as he as yet has done nothing on an NFL field.

Mack is worth a first? I'm thinking more like late 2nd at best

[Shoreline Steamers]

I like the trade for you, as I much prefer AB to Julio.

The fact that you were able to negotiate down to a 2nd from a 1st makes it that much more attractive to me.

[Pet_Smith]

Mack is worth a first? I'm thinking more like late 2nd at best

Yeah, I think he is. I wouldn't pay it, but the value is definitely late first. He's currently between Ridley and Kirk in ADP, was taken as an early second last year, and now has a "clearer" path to carries, so his value has risen. Again - I'm not interested him for that price, but that is his current value.

Swapping the first for a second is good on your part. Penny still a bit unknown, but I like the trade more for you now for sure