Dynasty League Football Forum

first my team: 12 team ppr league startup this year and i made a lot of trades and acquired 2019 picks
Q(1) Luck, Carr, Bradford, Allen
R(2-4) Kamara, Penny, Michel, Royce, CJA, Martin, Conner, Abdullah
W(3-5) Marvin, Lee, Godwin, Ross, Gallup, Pettis, JoBrown, Callaway, White, Ateman
T(1-3) Howard, Hurst, Gesicki

as you can see, i could use a WR upgrade (i do have 3 2019 1sts and 5 2019 2nds to address this issue)..not panicking but got an offer

i give Kamara
i get DT, Crowder, 2019 1st and 2019 2nd...

i rejected, but it got me thinking....perhaps i could make the same deal with Sony or Penny
so 2 questions:
1. would you trade one of those for that package?
2. which RB would you keep and which would you trade?

btw: i would probably take out the 2nd on the other side to balance it a little more

I'd likerade either Sony or Penny for that package, but I'm lower on them than most seem to be.

I would give either for that package. But if he wanted kamara...I don't think he values kamara the same as you two RBS as equals, so I don't think it gets done.

id pass out of a startup although this is tempting. id just be afraid the rb hits and traded away for that before 1 game.

you went in with the mindset of building a young team, not sure how dt and crowder fit into those plans before you've even set a line up. you have a nice "project" on your hands here and i like what you've done....but at some point...the players "mean more" than the picks....and really for you...youd be giving your rb for a future 1st and meh...just stand pat for this offer imo.

f he values those wr's..... who are his other wr's? maybe you could counter with a different wr option? he gets rb, you get wr type of move....

Your 19 1sts will net you plenty of young wr talent I'd stand pat and give this team a year or 2 to blossom

thanks everyone...i appreciate the responses...
how do you feel about mccaffrey
i might be able to get mccaffrey and 1st for sony or penny...not sure, but guy likes to trade and just acquired cmc

if you can get cmc and 1st for either, i would take it.

I would keep Penny and sell Michel if I did the trade.

I think you are overvaluing Sony and Penny. I think most people have CMC rated higher than Sony and Penny so there is no way the CMC side should add a first.

if you can get rid of sony or penny for cmc and a first id do it asap

McCaffrey is better than Michel or Penny. I'd also consider dealing either for DT and a first. Why not do both? Trade one for the DT package and the other for the McCaffrey package.

skip wrote: ↑Sat Jul 21, 2018 9:40 pm McCaffrey is better than Michel or Penny. I'd also consider dealing either for DT and a first. Why not do both? Trade one for the DT package and the other for the McCaffrey package.

i think i would rather have the young RB than DT and a first right now, that is a trade i would rather do in season if i needed a WR to make a run..

i greatly appreciate the help...thanks for the idea