Jordan Reed or George Kittle Value

[dawgs4life]

12 team non-PPR league start 1 TE 30man rosters.
I have Reed and Kittle. I also have McDonald (who I see as a big time sleeper this year) and Gerald Everett.
Was thinking of offering Reed or Kittle to an owner for 2.7, 2.12, and 3.10.
HE also has 1.11 and 1.12 but I know he wont give one of those for Reed straight up.

What do you guys think for either player for those draft picks, too light or too heavy?
Thx

[dawgs4life]

Or, what’s each value in draft pick straight up?
Reed for pick?
Kittle for pick?

[hawk2119]

I'm low on reed so I'd move him for those picks but I think you can get more for him. Not sure I'd trade kittle for that package, his upside is massive. If I'm selling I'd want something like 2.1-2.4 for either of them.

[Rosenbluu]

Kittle for me, Reeds injuries annoy me

[FKC]

Kittle for me, Reeds injuries annoy me

X2. Reed can't stay healthy.

[darewood11]

I'd much rather have kittle than reed. I'd say little worth early 2nd and reed to I guess but I would never give that. I don't even want to own reed

[Edgy68]

I'd hold Kittle unless I got a 1st, because I agree on his potential moving forward. If you can get a mid-2nd for Reed, I think you have to consider it. He's worth more healthy, but I think that ship has sailed and you'll do nothing but hold him. This takes up a roster spot with someone who will be stellar for a few games over the next season or two (before he decides he's had enough). I'd rather take a shot at someone who could develop, is younger/healthier, and could increase in value.