McCaffery or 1.07, 2 2019 (mid) firsts?

[austing]

Guy is interested in my McCaffery and offered 1.07 & 1.11. Considering countering for the 1.07 and his 2 2019 firsts for McCaffery as I have 1.02 (Guice), 1.03 (penny), 1.05 (Chubb/Michel) & 1.09 (kerryon/Freeman) this year and no 2019 firsts and only Keenan in my receiving core given next year should be good for receiver and I'm stocking up on rbs this year.. is that too much or too little in ppr for McCaffery you guys? This time of year I second guess everything..

[skip]

I definitely would reject his opening offer. Your counter is reasonable if you're willing to move McCaffrey.

[austing]

Yea this guy's a routinely poor offerer. I offer good trades imo that get accepted after negotiations most times while he only shoots out lottery ticket offers and prays for a accidental accept I think.. buuuut he really wants McCaffery so here I am.. yea a definite deny on the first offer.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

I'd sell McCaffrey for that. I'd reject the opening offer, but I wouldn't call it a poor opening offer.

[Goddard]

I definitely would reject his opening offer. Your counter is reasonable if you're willing to move McCaffrey.

Agree. Initial offer is pretty bad, but I'd probably move him for three 1sts.

[Flatlander19]

I agree reject his offer and do the counter offer

[ESKAY]

I didn’t think McCaffery was worth 3 firsts. So if you can get that then I would take it.

[FantasyFreak]

I didn’t think McCaffery was worth 3 firsts. So if you can get that then I would take it.

Yep

[Z$$$]

As a McCaffrey owner, would not do the first deal. The second deal is better if you can do it.

[jcc6fd]

3 firsts is an overpay for CMC

[FiremanEd]

I would definitely accept the three first option over McCaffery.

[BigBawseRoss]

try your idea i think it makes sense for you

[Vcize]

3 1sts > McCaffrey