Evans or keenan

[RTE]

Evans or keenan and by how much?

[joeya2001]

Evans
Evans________________________________Allen

This much

[Z$$$]

Allen

[thomasscheeks]

Keenan. Better offense, better receiver, Papa John's

[keebs3]

At this point it feels like it's nearly a toss up. Both have big upside and come with some risk. For this year I'm taking Keenan, but in a startup I'd grab Evans. He has a long future with Winston ahead of him.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Allen = Evans + 2nd

[Goddard]

Allen, but close. Not sure what the gap would be for me.

[Multiple Scorgasms]

For this year, it's definitely close but I like Allen without much of a 2nd thought. The reason is how much I fear those real ghost weeks from Evans. Last year, in a PPR league, Evans had weeks w/ 2.3, 5.3 and 4.5 points. Allen's worst game was 7.1, and that was at Denver. Also, Evans' catch rate is concerning.

Maybe it's not as close as I thought, but Evans is just such a freak athlete.

[topher]

Even, but in a startup I would take Evans if both there as he is younger and no injury history

[Big Al]

It is likely even for most but I'd pick with Evans.

[snuffalupicus]

Let me start by explaining my bias. I don't like Evans very much and I do like Allen, but to be subjective...I'd take Evans first for 2 big reasons.

Evans doesn't have the injury history that Allen has AND of course the Captain Obvious statement that Evans is a little younger. I do feel Allen is the more dynamic WR with better hands when he stays on the field. Both WRs should continue to produce for years to come...if Allen stays healthy. Side note, I did read an article a few years back on Allen saying he contemplated early retirement due to being often injured to pursue his passion in music. That was before being healthy all season last year.