Corey Davis for Baker Mayfield

[dynastywiz]

I was just offered Baker Mayfield for Corey Davis. This is a 2 QB league .5 ppr and I have posted my roster below. I am a little torn on this because I’m a big fan of Corey Davis. What do you guys think should I take the deal?


QB: Carson Wentz, Sam Bradford
RB: Leonard Fournette, James White, Jeremy Hill, Joe Mixon
WR: Danny Amendola, Tyler Boyd, Keenan Cole, Corey Coleman, Jamison Crowder, Josh Doctson, Taylor Gabriel, Ted Gunn Jr., Marquise Godwin, Tyreek Hill, Allen Hurns, Jermaine Kearse, Marquise Lee, Cameron Merideth, Braxton Miller, Terrell Pryor
TE: Eric Ebron, Jonnu Smith

TAXI SQUAD:
QB: DeShone Kizer, Sam Darnold
RB: Marlon Mack, D’Onta Foreman, Jamaal Williams, Derrick Guice, Saquan Barkley, Mark Walton
WR: Corey Davis, Curtis Samuel, Mike Williams, Antonio Callaway
TE: Adam Shaheen

[abloom]

How many teams in the league?

[dynastywiz]

10 team league

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Mayfield by a little in superflex, Mayfield by a lot in 2QB.

[skip]

Mayfield by a little in superflex, Mayfield by a lot in 2QB.

I agree. As bad as your WRs are, you still have to go with the better asset here.

[ddog2303]

I agree with the rest. Baker fairly easily here

[abloom]

Baker. Better chance he pans out and if he does you can trade him for an established wr in the future

[keebs3]

One more for Baker. You're team needs it more than Davis. Even though your team also really needs Davis.

[Titans95]

Mayfield by a little in superflex, Mayfield by a lot in 2QB.

Not that I disagree with Baker but why does superflex change vs 2QB? Its essentially the same setting. even the 30th ranked QB is more likely to outscore whatever your RB4 or WR4 is on any given week so if you aren't starting that QB in the SF you're already screwed

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Mayfield by a little in superflex, Mayfield by a lot in 2QB.

Not that I disagree with Baker but why does superflex change vs 2QB? Its essentially the same setting. even the 30th ranked QB is more likely to outscore whatever your RB4 or WR4 is on any given week so if you aren't starting that QB in the SF you're already screwed

Because if you only have 1 QB starting in superflex during any given week, you can make up those points with a RB, WR, or TE. If you only have 1 QB starting in 2QB during any given week, you are getting a 0 from a starting position. Pretty much all 1st and 2nd string QBs are owned in most 2QB leagues, which increases QB value slightly over superflex leagues.

[BigBawseRoss]

baker.

[Goddard]

That's a pretty fair offer and you can definitely use another starting QB on that team. WRs are easier to come by in 2QB leagues.

[dynastywiz]

I made the trade and to be honest my team needs everything.

[Johnny Canuck]

Mayfield by a little in superflex, Mayfield by a lot in 2QB.

I agree. As bad as your WRs are, you still have to go with the better asset here.

^this 100%

[dblj1199]

Your team is still a few years off. So with a trio of Wentz, Darnold and Mayfield you, assuming both rookies pan out, are totally set at AB for the next 10 yrs. So at draft time it allows you to build your roster while no having to add the “next” qb.