Cooper for A Package?

[Farley]

I've got a pretty solid team that doesn't have much depth. Been offered this for my Cooper:

Give: Amari
Get: Collins, Parker, Godwin, and 2019 1st (likely mid)

My key players and league settings below.

Start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 2Flex - ppr (1.5 for TEs)
Big Ben, Mariota
Zeke, Barkley, McKinnon
Thomas, Cooper, Diggs, Moore, Cobb
Ertz, Njuko

Any thoughts would be appreciated. Thanks so much.

[Cowboysfan33]

It’s a solid offer and it would definitely help you with depth but I think keeping Cooper helps you win now, more than the package. I think your team looks strong so I would probably pass on that deal.

[dhanks91]

Keep cooper. I think he’s primed for a bounce back. He may never be that stud wr1 everyone thought, but I see him being more of a super dependable wr2

[IR1]

Close, voted Cooper, may have taken the package if rebuilding and could flip Collins and Parker

[FantasyFreak]

Cooper. Most likely the only player relevant in 3 years (other than the first).

[hudini33]

Keep cooper. I think he’s primed for a bounce back. He may never be that stud wr1 everyone thought, but I see him being more of a super dependable wr2

This is how I feel about him. I don't think he'll ever be in the top 5 wr, but I can see him consistently being in the 10-15 range of that bottom WR1, top WR2 range.

Keep Cooper.

[kellysheroes]

i'll keep cooper and give him a chance

[cvbuc]

This is very close.

It boils down to whether you believe Godwin or Parker will break out to WR2 level or not.
Parker has had 3 years to prove himself. Not saying he can't be decent, but the odds of him becoming a WR1 all of a sudden are not good.
Godwin has that "it" factor. He also has a 25 year old WR on his team entrenched at the WR1 spot and a huge looming QB fiasco in Tampa now. He has the talent but his ceiling is capped.

Collins is solid - but would it really surprise anyone if Dixon came on strong and made a bit of a mess of the situation? It would not surprise me.

And then there's the pick.

The sum of the parts is greater than Cooper - but you can't definitively see a route where any of the pieces become as valuable or more than Cooper - who has his own opportunity to "break out" this year.

I'd actually pursue the idea of this trade - but I'd try to swap out a piece or two into players with a higher ceiling potentially.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I'd happily sell Cooper for that, but I'm not as high on him as most.

[skip]

The value is there, but the need isn't. None of those pieces would be starting for you. I guess maybe you have to be a believer in Parker to make the trade and I'm not.

[topher]

It’s a fair offer value wise on paper because all these pieces add up to Cooper. The best piece being the 2019 pick.

I would easily stick with Cooper here

[Shcritters]

One more for the Cooper side

[Farley]

This is very close.

It boils down to whether you believe Godwin or Parker will break out to WR2 level or not.
Parker has had 3 years to prove himself. Not saying he can't be decent, but the odds of him becoming a WR1 all of a sudden are not good.
Godwin has that "it" factor. He also has a 25 year old WR on his team entrenched at the WR1 spot and a huge looming QB fiasco in Tampa now. He has the talent but his ceiling is capped.

Collins is solid - but would it really surprise anyone if Dixon came on strong and made a bit of a mess of the situation? It would not surprise me.

And then there's the pick.

The sum of the parts is greater than Cooper - but you can't definitively see a route where any of the pieces become as valuable or more than Cooper - who has his own opportunity to "break out" this year.

I'd actually pursue the idea of this trade - but I'd try to swap out a piece or two into players with a higher ceiling potentially.

I think Parker is a WR3 with upside this year. And Godwin becomes a WR2 next year...once DeSean is out of the picture. I also think Collins is safe RB2. He won't have much value after the season, imo. But I'd flip him early in the offseason.

Cooper worries me. His value falls off a CLIFF if he has anywhere close to a repeat of last season.

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

cooper

[playa_hata]

10 team league easily keep cooper. 12 team league i would still keep cooper but would be more enticing.