Keenan - B.Cooks trade

[PercyR1]

.5 ppr 12 team

What side

[Goddard]

I'd pay that for Keenan if I was trying to compete. Looks fair either way though.

[Titans95]

KA Side

[topher]

I like KA, but I prefer the package side here

[smallxl]

I would trade KA for that

[Cowboysfan33]

I would give that for KA, if I was a serious contender, but it’s close enough, that I would pass otherwise.

[footballwookie]

Package, just my opinion. Cooks should be solid.

[keebs3]

That's a solid package. I like both sides. I'd probably lean Keenan, as I'm all about the side with the best player in the deal. Especially a solid WR1.
I sent a solid package with Cooks in order to get MT, and I value Keenan in the same tier.

[thomasscheeks]

Keenan side pretty easily for me. There's a fairly large gap between him and Cooks

[bills2]

I voted package side, think it's just too much value to pass on. Can see why people would go KA side though

[JJRules]

I voted KA as I generally prefer to get the best player in a trade, but I wasn't surprised in the least to see this at a 50/50 split vote. It's a really fair offer either way, so personal preference is fine here.

[RTE]

Man healthy Keenan has proven he's top5. All on his health

[PercyR1]

I never try and "win" trades. i think if it helps both teams accomplish what they are trying to do it keeps the league happy.
The team buying Cooks is going rebuild and i was looking to add some stability to my WR core with a target monster high floor type WR.

Also with Hunter Henry out Keenan should without a doubt finish as a top 3 WR imo.

thanks for the votes and comments

[JDogil12]

Fair trade but I lean slightly towards the package

[HughHoney]

Fair trade as shown by the even poll split so far. Very close but Allen by a slim margin for me.