Hilton + Ingram for Melvin Gordon

[Gandalf]

Number of Teams: 13 teams with 30 man rosters
League settings: 0.5 PPR, standard scoring otherwise
Starting Lineup: 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 2Flex (WR/RB/TE), TE, DST, K

I give:

• TY Hilton

• Mark Ingram

I get:

• Melvin Gordon

Current Roster:
QB: Roethlisberger, Mariota, Keenum
RB: Hyde, Ingram, Tevin, Gio, Abdullah, J-Stew, Peyton Barber, Mike Davis, Rawls
WR: Nuk, Keenan, Julio, ARob, T.Y. Hilton, JuJu, Lockett, Trent Taylor, Kendrick Bourne, Tyler Boyd
TE: Ertz, Eifert, Vance McDonald

2018 Draft Stock: 3.09, 4.12, 5.01, 5.12
2019 Draft Stock: 3rd, 4th (2), 5th (2)

My search for an RB1 continues and Melvin Gordon is the next target. Do you all think this is a fair offer?

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I think it's pretty fair, and you have the WR depth to make this move.

[Goddard]

Seems fair to me. Hilton and Gordon are probably close, and Ingram should close the gap. I'd prefer the Gordon side of this deal, especially for your team.

[Rosenbluu]

Gordon side and you need the RB

[topher]

As of right now I’d say that’s a good deal, but are you willing to wait? I feel if Luck is assured to come back and plays game 1, it will just take 1-2 games of him and Hilton to increase his value.

Hilton for me is a strong candidate to have his value skyrocket if Luck is back healthy.

[Gandalf]

As of right now I’d say that’s a good deal, but are you willing to wait? I feel if Luck is assured to come back and plays game 1, it will just take 1-2 games of him and Hilton to increase his value.

Hilton for me is a strong candidate to have his value skyrocket if Luck is back healthy.

I'd rather get an RB1 now because my league will hold me at a ransom if the season arrives and I don't have one. Oddly enough, Hilton's value has held steady in my league and he's still being treated as a boom/bust WR1.

I've proposed the offer and the owner is thinking on it. My league values RBs far more than WRs so I won't be surprised if this one is shot down.

[BigBawseRoss]

much prefer the hilton ingram side