Engram+picks for Watkins/Ajayi/TColeman

[Killabrewster]

I haven't posted much on this forum in a little while, but I'm really struggling with a trade offer that's currently on the table for Team 2 below (roster limit is 20, but my roster is massive right now due to the draft and the fact we don't cut players until end of preseason). I think I may be slightly losing this trade, but my desire to A. not be an absolute dumpster fire this year (I don't own my own 1st in 2019), and B. not be too heavily invested in the 2019 draft between both leagues, especially considering I don't like next year's class very much, have me giving it serious consideration. See below:

Give: Evan Engram, 2019 early-to-mid 1st*, 2019 late 1st
Get: Sammy Watkins, Jay Ajayi, Tevin Coleman

*I would conditionally receive a 2020 1st if this pick falls between picks 1-4

I have five tight ends, so I can definitely part with one of them, but I really struggle with including Engram here as he would probably be the most valuable single asset being traded. With that said, I am rather high on Ajayi this year, and I like the idea of getting Coleman a year before he hits free agency.

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

[Goddard]

Really would depend on where that early/mid 2019 1st ends up. If it's very early, I like that side. If it's mid, I think it's even. If it's late, I'd take the Sammy side. I guess getting a 2020 1st helps if the 2019 1sts end up being top 4, so can see going either way here.

[topher]

I would not make the trade, I like your side a lot more.

[metalmat]

I like Coleman but not in the Watkins or Ajayi camp at all. I would take Engram and the picks

[Jmatt>Coleman]

I like what you are giving more than what you are getting. Mainly because it’s a total win now move. However unless a lot of things go right you are still no better than middle of the pack. Stay the course. If you like Ajayi offer the late first.

I also don’t get the free agency thing with coleman. He could tear an acl, he could plain suck, or he could not get a featured role next year. The pick gains value coleman may lose value.