Player Trade TE for QB - OTC

[Snickers]

I am OTC at the moment at pick 13.5

QB - Matt Ryan
RB - Guice, Freeman, Thompson, Du. Johnson, C. Anderson.
WR - Evans, Theilen, Robinson, Shepard, Ridley
TE - Rudolph, Njoku

I was proposed this trade:

A. Njoku
2019 1st (likely to be a high first)

B. Luck
2019 1st (likely to be an early first)
Gesicki

His team:

QB - Newton, Mahomes, Luck
RB - Jones, Chubb, Miller, A. Jones
WR - Thomas, Jones, Gordon
TE - Gesicki

[joeday]

With the pick likely being top 5 I reject this. But I may be in the minority.

[Snickers]

With the pick likely being top 5 I reject this. But I may be in the minority.

I posted his current team too to show why I think it might be a bottom five or early first rounder.

Edit: I made a mistake in my wording. Look again at the trade proposed.

[hudini33]

I'm taking the Luck side. Getting Luck and an upgraded 1st for Njoku would be worth it for me. Plus you get Gesicki too.

[skip]

I'm not buying anything telling me whether a future pick is early or late during a startup draft. The picks aren't even a factor in the deal. And looking at the teams, they are very close anyway.

It's Njoku for Luck. I like Njoku but I can't see any justification for picking him over Luck unless there has been a sudden report telling us Luck is expected to miss 2018

[Johnny Canuck]

Gotta go with the Luck side here quite easily. I even think Gesicki has a decent chance to outproduce Njoku this yr simply due to targets/opportunity.

[BigBawseRoss]

luck side very very very easily without any amount of thought at all.