What Side You Got? Melvin, and ARob for Cooks+

[AlbertaPrime]

Was just offered the following:

Give: ARob and Melvin
Get: Brandin Cooks, 2019 1st and 2020 1st

My first thought was no on this but curious what the community thinks. This leaves me really thin at RB. I really do not feel comfortable running with Alex Collins and 2018 1.7.

Is the general consensus that ARob = Cooks? Or do you guys favor one versus the other? ADP has them pretty close.

[Shcritters]

So this is essentially Melvin for 2 1sts. Personally I wouldn’t do it, but I’d rather have ARob and Gordon. Non-ppr makes it closer, but I’d still lean that direction.

[Cowboysfan33]

Pass for me too.

[Goddard]

Keep your guys.

[AlbertaPrime]

Thanks for the feedback you guys. Always good to this type of feedback.

I countered with the following...

Give: ARob, Dak and Parker
Receive: Cooks, Jimmy and 2020 1st

[Titans95]

2020 1sts is absolutely useless I think its dumb people can trade 1st round picks more than a year away. Keep your guys

[Pats/VikesFan]

In non-ppr, Melvin is more valuable than the two first rounders (especially considering next year's RB class looks thin).

[topher]

Keep your guys. If the 2019 pick projects top 3 then this is a close offer but that’s a lot of risk.

[Belichickians]

I would pass.

[topher]

2020 1sts is absolutely useless I think its dumb people can trade 1st round picks more than a year away. Keep your guys

I have heard on more than 1 occasion that the 2020 class is better than 2019. Now I don’t know enough about either to have an opinion and I personally feel it’s difficult to say with certainty which is better at this point in time, but if you’re someone who is in tune with devy and concurs, than a 2020 could be more valuable than 2019.

[thomasscheeks]

Not close at all. Easy pass