Rodgers for Wentz

[Mathew11]

Team in Sig.

In a Dynasty league, who should add in this deal?
The other manager really wants Rodgers from me. He said he's only willing to add a mid pick.

He has the following players...

Wentz, DJ, OBJ, Diggs, J.Gordon, JuJu, Landry, D.Thomas & Eifert.

[joeday]

I prefer Wentz but in your situation I would probably stay put unless you can do something like Rodgers, Fuller, 2.1 for Wentz, JuJu or Diggs

[Mathew11]

I prefer Wentz but in your situation I would probably stay put unless you can do something like Rodgers, Fuller, 2.1 for Wentz, JuJu or Diggs

I was thinking exactly that. He has a ton of WRs. Would love JuJu but then that would give me 3 Steelers

[thomasscheeks]

I would take Wentz and a mid pick for Rodgers. They should put up very similar numbers and Wentz has the obvious age advantage. Sounds like a free pick to me

[Checker1183]

I would take Wentz and a mid pick for Rodgers. They should put up very similar numbers and Wentz has the obvious age advantage. Sounds like a free pick to me

Was thinking the same

[hudini33]

I prefer Wentz but in your situation I would probably stay put unless you can do something like Rodgers, Fuller, 2.1 for Wentz, JuJu or Diggs

I was thinking exactly that. He has a ton of WRs. Would love JuJu but then that would give me 3 Steelers

Ask for Diggs then. I prefer him over Juju anyway

[Mathew11]

If I can only get a pick, how high should I ask for?

[Goddard]

If I can only get a pick, how high should I ask for?

Late 1st or early 2nd...doubt you get that though.

[Mathew11]

If I can only get a pick, how high should I ask for?

Late 1st or early 2nd...doubt you get that though.

He offered Wentz and his 5th for Rodgers.
Is it even worth it or hold on to Rodgers.

[Goddard]

If I can only get a pick, how high should I ask for?

Late 1st or early 2nd...doubt you get that though.

He offered Wentz and his 5th for Rodgers.
Is it even worth it or hold on to Rodgers.

That's basically an even swap. Don't see any reason why you would make that trade. Just keep the better QB.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

He offered Wentz and his 5th for Rodgers. Is it even worth it or hold on to Rodgers?

Pass. I'd much rather have Rodgers over Wentz. Regression is coming for Wentz regardless, and he may even start the season on PUP. Wentz tore both his ACL and LCL, and many seem to be assuming 100% health without pricing in injury risk, much like with Dalvin Cook's current value.

[thomasscheeks]

If I can only get a pick, how high should I ask for?

Late 1st or early 2nd...doubt you get that though.

He offered Wentz and his 5th for Rodgers.
Is it even worth it or hold on to Rodgers.

Yeah a fifth does nothing for me. I would need at least a late second to consider it. Even though Wentz is younger, I would still rather have Rodgers if it's basically a straight up trade

[Favrezilla]

Rodgers will score more for the next 2-3 years, but how much more? and that what is the price of going from a the top QB to the 2nd or 3rd best QB in the NFL?

[Titans95]

In a superflex I took Wentz over rodgers in a startup but in 1 QB league where your team is ready to compete now I'd hang on to rodgers, He's still going to be ELITE for 5-6 more years

[Vcize]

Rodgers will score more for the next 2-3 years, but how much more? and that what is the price of going from a the top QB to the 2nd or 3rd best QB in the NFL?

I own Wentz and really like him, but the issue isn't about dropping to the 2nd or 3rd best QB, it's about dropping to a guy that could be anywhere from the 2nd best QB to the next Matt Stafford to the next RG3. We've seen a lot of young QBs look really elite for a year and then fade back more into the pack.