I was offered Cooks for 1.5 (Chubb or Michel)...

[joeday]

I need help at both positions. It is a 12 team PPR league. Would you trade Chubb or Michel for Brandin Cooks? Rankings tell me to do it, but I am hesitant.

[Titans95]

I'd do that

[JDogil12]

In a vacuum, Cooks over both. He is still 24, and has had a pretty historic start to his career. I'm not too worried about the Watkins comparisons because this time McVay has a whole training camp to work with him instead of Watkins who had weeks
Win-Now, I would keep Michel. Past 2019, I would prefer Chubb
Edit: thought you had both, my bad. I would still take Cooks but ignore that last line

[keebs3]

I would take Cooks over them, and I like both guys.

[Cowboysfan33]

I would take Cooks over them, and I like both guys.

This for me. I like all three players but Cooks has been so solid every season and I think being paired with a innovative coach like McVay and a good young team around him, we haven’t seen his ceiling yet, imo. He’s still young too, just 24.

[Johnny Canuck]

I’d take either RB over Cooks. Chubb if ur looking more longterm, Sony if u need immediate production.

Cooks is fools gold. Yes he’s been good...but the guy has only had Brees and Brady as his QB! Have fun with Goff. NTM Goff is in line for massive regression. And that LA Rams defense is legit, I predict very littlenegative game scripts. So just like Forest Gump, they’ll just keep running and running. They won’t be taking long bomb shots to Cooks, or airing it out to play catch up. McVay is great but he spreads the ball around, Cooks won’t be breaking 100 targets, and he won’t even be the RZ weapon that sammy was. With cooks you’re getting Watkins from 2017 with more yardage but less TDs...no thanks. Don’t get me wrong he’ll still be usable, but he’ll be more of a WR18-26 from this point fwd.

Gimme Chubb or Sony all day over Cooks. Easy money right there.

[Vcize]

I also like all of these guys but would prefer Cooks. He is unferrrated imo.

[Goddard]

I'd do Chubb first.

[Rosenbluu]

Cooks

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Cooks >= Michel >= Chubb

[BigBawseRoss]

chubb>cooks>michel

[Mathew11]

Give me Cooks. Still young and will build chemistry with Goff.

[hudini33]

Who went top 4 that leaves you with the choice of Chubb and Michel?

I would go cooks here though.

[joeday]

Who went top 4 that leaves you with the choice of Chubb and Michel?

I would go cooks here though.

It went Barkley, Guice, Penny, RoJo...I took Michel with my thinking that I could still get cooks if I wanted to for him.

[Pats/VikesFan]

This year: Cooks
For the Future: Chubb