TE Offer, poll included

[brewster]

Received an offer of:

Gesicki for HHenry

My team is built to win now and Hunter was my main TE but do I make this trade straight up or just play the waiver wire with guys like Ian Thomas, Cook, James, McDonald, Wilson (DET), Akins available? I feel like the value is still on the Henry side. It's PPR scoring and it is a dynasty league.

[esloan35]

Get Gesicki and a waiver guy. Gotta have a good TE to make a run. There will be more Hunter Henry player types. Gesicki may be better??

[Gordon09]

I'd keep Henry, but not a Gesicki fan.

Even in your situation, I don't think Gesicki guarantees 2018 production, may end up rolling with a Vance McDonald or Jared Cook anyway. Olsen or Walker are better targets if they're available if you're trying to win this year.

[Slackalacker]

I’d like HH seems like a good buy to me.

[Johnny Canuck]

Love Gesicki this season, would rather have him.

Also many here are not considering the value of a free roster spot for ww pickups in season, or not having to drop a decent player for other injuries/bye weeks etc. Unless you have 25+ player rosters I’d rather have Gesicki and the open roster spot.

[lukkynumber13]

I'd keep Henry, but not a Gesicki fan.

Even in your situation, I don't think Gesicki guarantees 2018 production, may end up rolling with a Vance McDonald or Jared Cook anyway. Olsen or Walker are better targets if they're available if you're trying to win this year.

x2

Gesicki is nowhere near what Engram was last year. He won't be a producer this year. Henry is the much better player, don't sell him so cheap.

[lukkynumber13]

Love Gesicki this season, would rather have him.

Also many here are not considering the value of a free roster spot for ww pickups in season, or not having to drop a decent player for other injuries/bye weeks etc. Unless you have 25+ player rosters I’d rather have Gesicki and the open roster spot.

How would OP get an extra roster spot? He'd be giving away the IR player...