Youth Package or Gurley? Poll

[Johnny Canuck]

I’ve got a contending team with some solid pieces from this recent draft class, another team annouced they are rebuilding, thinking of offering up a youth package of: Chubb, Sony, Gesicki, Fuller, 2019 2nd (I don’t have my 1st) for Gurley.

Is this enough for Gurley? Too much? Or a fair trade?

[Johnny Canuck]

My thoughts on the deal are this...

I personally feel like Chubb and Sony both have future top 8 RB written all over them so I’m finding it difficult to gauge this deal. It also doesn’t help that I’m high on Fuller and Gesicki.

Obvs Gurley is the best player in the deal, but man, it sure feels like a lot of assets to give up.

I think it might make sense for both sides in the end, getting Gurley would really solidfy my chances for a championship run, and getting those assets could really accelerate a rebuild imo. What are your thoughts?

[lukkynumber13]

Gurley for sure. Not close for me.

[playa_hata]

if this is for the team in youre signature you dont really have much of a choice gurley would all but solidify a ship

[RAB]

Gurley is the youth package you want

[kellysheroes]

Gurley is the youth package you want

lol, yes!!! hes only been in 3 yrs

[topher]

This was a tough one. I voted Gurley. Really like Chubb though and I'm ok with Sony. Don't really care for Fuller and the rest, so that's why I went for Gurley.

[Favrezilla]

Gurley for sure. Not close for me.

Agreed. If you want to get Gurley from an owner you need to have at least one stud and then all he picks/youth filler.

[skip]

Aside from Chubb and Fuller, I'm not interested in the pieces on the other side and those two aren't close to Gurley in value. The deal is a very easy one to make.

[Trevormortis]

Gurley pretty easy

[Johnny Canuck]

**This is an old thread from last offseason**

Just thought it was interesting and possibly beneficial to show how drastically situations can change in a short period of time.

Everyone was leaning Gurley this time last yr, fast forward one yr later, and Chubb is being held at equal value to Gurley, and everything else would just be gravy on top.

2019 Valuation
Chubb =< Gurley
Sony, Fuller, Gesicki, 2019 2nd for free pretty much

Funny how things can change in just one yr

[Gator Sens]

**This is an old thread from last offseason**

Just thought it was interesting and possibly beneficial to show how drastically situations can change in a short period of time.

Everyone was leaning Gurley this time last yr, fast forward one yr later, and Chubb is being held at equal value to Gurley, and everything else would just be gravy on top.

2019 Valuation
Chubb =< Gurley
Sony, Fuller, Gesicki, 2019 2nd for free pretty much

Funny how things can change in just one yr

Very interesting to see this seed from last year. I was actually really surprised reading the comments before getting to this one ha ha.

[LMS123]

I’m surprised by this, I’ve seen a lot of people in the past say Chubb alone over Gurley now. And with Sony on top that’s nice. I’d probably sell my Gurley for that