Godwin Value Compared to incoming rookies

[Perry_Grin13]

I have the 1.12 Pick and likely will be looking at WR with the Top RB mostly gone by that time. Godwin is available, but not sure how he compares to incoming class as this is my first rookie draft.

[playa_hata]

i would take moore, ridley, kirk, sutton, miller, gallup, pettis, washington over godwin.

[Cherokee]

Its Miller, Moore, Kirk, Goodwin, Ridley for me. Not interested in Sutton Pettis Washington nor Gallup

[playa_hata]

Its Miller, Moore, Kirk, Goodwin, Ridley for me. Not interested in Sutton Pettis Washington nor Gallup

godwin has little upside to me i would happily taken any of this years wr over godwin he we will be career 3rd-4th option he has evans, brate/howard and rojo all ahead of hi on the target list.

[M-Dub]

As a Godwin owner, the only one I’d trade him for is Moore. The poll wouldn’t let me only vote for him.

[Cherokee]

Its Miller, Moore, Kirk, Goodwin, Ridley for me. Not interested in Sutton Pettis Washington nor Gallup

godwin has little upside to me i would happily taken any of this years wr over godwin he we will be career 3rd-4th option he has evans, brate/howard and rojo all ahead of hi on the target list.

Trying to think of where Gallup, Ridley, Sutton, Pettis Washington and even Kirk would slot in on their food chains. I dont understand why Godwin is pegged there for his whole career. Let me ask you where DJax is as an option now? Is he not still the no. 2? 98 targets last year with 50ish catches. Godwin nearly matched his numbers on 20 less catches. IDK though

[Chwf3rd]

Don’t understand the Godwin love aft all.

1. Moore
2. Ridley
3. Miller
4. Kirk
5. Sutton
6. Gallup
7. Callaway
8. Godwin
9. Washington

[topher]

Kirk, Moore, Miller, Washington I'd take over Godwin.

[HughHoney]

All the options listed except Gallup and Washington.

[RAB]

All the options listed except Gallup and Washington.

Yup. This^

[Perry_Grin13]

Thanks everyone for input. I could see Godwin sliding into the WR2 role in tampa with D-jax on back 9 of his career and passing Humphies on depth chart. He also is a year more progressed a position that usually takes 2-4 years to become relevant.

[Needalife]

Is Godwin a first round startup pick yet?!?!? Man, the hype is too much for my taste. His lack of obvious role clarity puts him in Anthony Miller territory for me even if he gets the #2 job. I’m not sure Jameis is a lock to support multiple fantasy WR starters. We shall see. I liked Godwin for a while but I feel like his value has gotten a bit high. Great time to sell if I owned him. I’d trade him for a first in a heartbeat.

[Big Al]

In a recent PPR start-up, 3 rookies went before Godwin (Moore, Ridley and Kirk). Moore is the only one I would trade him for.

[Goddard]

Moore might be the only one.

[Space Cowboy]

I'd take Godwin over all of them.