Pick a side

[fantasydem]

Team 3 in signature:

Was offered Luck, 2019 1st (probably mid) and a couple throw ins that I’ll more than likely drop, Fat Rob & Kearse for my Wentz, Sony Michel & Delanie Walker.

First impression: decent offer but decline bc it will leave me with 0 RBs in a league that awards RBs .25 ppc. I want to get rid of Walker as my team is in no position to compete probably for a couple years so he doesn’t do much for me. I still prefer Luck to Wentz (I’m a Colts fan so that is a little bias) so it really comes down to moving Michel.

His only other two RBs of relevance are Marlon Mack & Derrick Henry. The owner is also a Colts & Bama fan so I feel I would have to overpay for both of those guys and I’m not so sure I want to do that or even can do that.

Curious what your guys’ thoughts are?

[Z$$$]

Wentz and Michel

[JDogil12]

Wentz>>Luck
Michel>>2019 first
Walker>Throw ins
Don't think this offer is close

[R2D2]

Wentz>>Luck
Michel>>2019 first
Walker>Throw ins
Don't think this offer is close

x2

[lukkynumber13]

Wentz>>Luck
Michel>>2019 first
Walker>Throw ins
Don't think this offer is close

The assets on the left are not as superior to the assets on the right as this post implies, but I agree overall that this trade doesn't make sense for you. It's a lateral move at best, meaning if Luck comes back healthy it's still not really improving your team overall.

[Dusticlez1]

Yeah not very close at all... Luck hasn’t proven that he’s his old self yet and I’m guessing you spent an early-mid 1st in Michel...so why let him go for a future 1st? The trade simply doesn’t make any sense either...lateral move like the above said with all the risk on the Luck side.