Engram, Kelce or Ertz

[ravn88]

I recently traded for Engram for my team in sig.

The owner of Kelce is 1.04, he got a few piecies like AB, Matt Ryan and Kelvin Benjamin.
The Ertz owner is 1.05, he is in massive rebuild his only player other than Ertz is Watson.

Who would you rather have for a win now team of the 2 ?

I intend to ask them straight up for either..

I do have Wentz if that tips the scale.

[JJRules]

I'd prefer Ertz here due laregly to not knowing how Mahomes will spread the ball or even how he will perform in general. Otherwise they're a wash and down to personal preference.

[thomasscheeks]

Kelce is easily the top guy here, and probably a waste of time trying to swap 1 for 1. If you can trade Engram for Ertz straight up, you should jump all over it. But honestly, keeping Engram doesn't hurt

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Kelce >= Ertz > Engram. You can try the straight up offers, but I doubt they'll be accepted. I'd try Engram + Aaron Jones.

[Johnny Canuck]

I'd take either of Ertz or Kelce over Engram. Think I'd prefer Kelce over Ertz but only by a small margin.

[cvbuc]

Kelce - not that close
Ertz injured more often
Not that much younger
Philly just snatched a 2nd round TE

[M-Dub]

I prefer Kelce to Ertz, but getting either of them straight up for Engram would be a huge win.

[vixen]

i would prefer Kelce as well...Engram is due for a bit of regression since OBJ is coming back and NYG added Barkley (likely less passing attempts)
so i have Kelce>>>Ertz>Engram...but i don't know why anyone would just swap...

[lukkynumber13]

For me personally, I would rank them Kelce, Engram, Ertz

[keebs3]

I own Engram- and have though about trying to trade for Ertz by adding a smaller piece, like Jones. His regression this year has me worried- and he dropped a lot of passes last year, too.

However, the more I thought about it, the more I realized their values are pretty even. Engram is younger and the Eagles just drafted another TE. I'm still taking Ertz first if I had the choice, but don't think it's worth it to give up an additional piece with Engram to get Ertz.
As the others have said, if you can do it straight up sure- but it seems like you're flipping a coin at that point.

[Ice]

Kelce by a mile.....NOT CLOSE I like Engram by a nose over Ertz.

Like all 3 but Kelce is top 3 with top 1 upside at the position.

[Hawks Nest 12th Man]

Tricky one. This time next year Engram could be valued higher than Kelce or Ertz. I personally prefer Engram over all TEs in fantasy. I would need to watch every single target before making assumptions on drops. For 1 season I rank Ertz, Kelce, Engram but it’s close. Ertz gets nicked up a lot, Kelce lost QB, OC and Watkins added to mix. Giants got better O Line, OC and added legit RB. My concern with Engram is consistency. He is clearly 3rd option in offense. Engram is a freak athlete at TE coming off pro bowl season as rookie.