jeffery or watkins?

[vixen]

in a 12 team ppr superflex league, i am rebuilding (my team is pretty bad)
QB: Jimmy GQ, Cousins, Bradford
RB: Fournette, Ingram, Blount, Booker, Rd Smith, McKissic
WR: Jeffery, Agholor, Stills, Jo Brown, Doctson, Conley
TE: Cook, Kroft

i got an offer
i give Jeffery
i get Watkins

what do you think?

EDIT: the owner of watkins does not own a 2019 3rd and i do not own a 2019 2nd, so i how does everyone feel about
i give Jeffery and Ingram
i get Watkins and 2019 1st? (likely 10-12 range)

[Belichickians]

Jeffrey for me. Fairly close though so if the Watkins owner adds I’d consider the move

[keebs3]

I like Jeffrey too, by a smidgen

[EverFTN]

I'm encouraged by the way Jeffery came on at the end of the year. Philly seems to want to spread it around, so I doubt he'll ever reach his heights with Chicago, but I think he has a higher floor than Watkins.

Sammy has a hypothetical unseen ceiling, but McVay couldn't tap into it. Can Andy Reid? Possible.

[Goddard]

Agree with the two above, Sammy side should add something small.

[Cowboysfan33]

Jeffery for me too.

[HughHoney]

Personal preference. Mine is Sammy.

[esloan35]

Jeffery...

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Personal preference. Mine is Sammy.

x2 I prefer Watkins by a slight margin, but market value is on the side of Jeffery. I'd ask for Watkins + 2019 2nd since he came to you. If he doesn't want to do that, counter with Watkins + 2019 3rd. If he wants Jeffery, that should get it done.

[lilsoapjetski]

I think it boils down to personal preference but I'd take Alshon. Maybe try to see if you can get the Watkins owner to throw a pick on as someone else said

[Johnny Canuck]

Jeffery.

[joeya2001]

I don't like either

But Jeffery is more reliable.

[Snake]

Jeffery pretty easily. He played the full year with a torn rotator cuff and looked pretty good. Excited to see what he can do healthy with Wentz this year. Expecting 1,000 yards and 10 TDs

Watkins, I think is the #3 guy behind Hill/Kelce.

[The.Big.Spank]

I've never been a big fan of either, but I think Watkins finally reaches WR1 status. Mahommes loves to chuck that ball downfield and show off that arm and with Hill on the other side and Hunt keeping the secondary honest, I think Sammy could finally have that moster year and become the Wr everybody has always thought he was.

Jeffrey is always injured, like Watkins, but he tends to show up a little out of shape and now that he has got paid I am even more worried about his football focus.

[vixen]

i am torn, the owner of Watkins only has 4th round picks this year...
2019 no third round pick, has a 2nd round pick, but i think that may be an overpay (asking for a 2nd), i don't have a 3rd round pick in 2019.

i could take it to another level and try
i give Jeffery and Ingram
i get Watkins and 2019 1st? what do you think about that trade?