Trade help on this one needed please.

[kris_kapsner]

I did a load of trading to get the 1.1 and 1.3 in this year's rookie draft with my team below. I'm excited to pair David Johnson with Barkley.

There is an owner who is very high on one of the rookie RB's in this draft and is wanting to do a conditional trade with me should his guy be available at 1.3 in our draft tomorrow night.

Here is the offer to me:

He gets:
1.3
Tom Brady
2nd next year


I get

Matt Stafford
Kenyan Drake
2.4
2.7
1st in 2021
4th and 6th round picks next year

What are your thoughts?

I do get 10 years younger at QB and I like Stafford. I also like Drake quite a bit and the offer really boils down to how much I value him. I do have Gore to pair up with him for RB's behind my starting duo of DJ and Barkley.

[thomasscheeks]

That's pretty terrible imo. The first alone is worth more than that

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

That's pretty terrible. A 2021 1st in a 16-team league is a complete crapshoot. The 1.03 alone is worth more than the entire other side of this deal. The 2.04 and 2.07 are also not worth as much in a 16-team format. I'd counter with 1.03 alone for Stafford + Drake + 2.04 + 2.07 + 2021 1st.

[R2D2]

1.3
Tom Brady
2nd next year

Kenyan Drake
2.4
2.7
1st in 2021
4th and 6th round picks next year

Brady = Stafford (age bias)
2.4 + 2.7 + Drake < 1.3
2021 1st is far away and probably compares to 2nd next year.

I get the extra picks will help in replenishing QB/WR, but I think they are a bit too late in a 16 man league to help effectively.

[Johnny Canuck]

Not enough. The 1.03 is worth more alone than the package he's offering.

You're better off holding unless he's willing to significantly upgrade his offer.

[The.Big.Spank]

That's pretty terrible. A 2021 1st in a 16-team league is a complete crapshoot. The 1.03 alone is worth more than the entire other side of this deal. The 2.04 and 2.07 are also not worth as much in a 16-team format. I'd counter with 1.03 alone for Stafford + Drake + 2.04 + 2.07 + 2021 1st.

I kinda like this one. Thats a good deal in a 16 teamer.

[mike40]

I say find out who he wants so badly, take him if you like him then hold out for his best offer. You know he's in talks with the 1.04 and probably the 1.05 owner trying to do the same thing with them

[PercyR1]

rubbish offer!

[kris_kapsner]

These responses are very interesting.

Most ranking lists I can find have Kenyan Drake ahead or neck in neck in value with any of the other rookie RB's I'd be able to draft at 1.3.

Brady, though better than Stafford, is only 30 and a perennial good scoring QB. In most any ranking list I can find I see Stafford ranked ahead of Brady.

Then I'm getting a future 1st and some 2nd's this year just to add frosting.

I guess I'm surprised at the responses. But, that's why I asked the question. I didn't think it was all that bad of an offer.

[kris_kapsner]

These responses are very interesting.

Most ranking lists I can find have Kenyan Drake ahead or neck in neck in value with any of the other rookie RB's I'd be able to draft at 1.3.

Stafford, though not as good as Brady, is only 30 and a perennial good scoring QB. In most any ranking list I can find I see Stafford ranked ahead of Brady.

Then I'm getting a future 1st and some 2nd's this year just to add frosting.

I guess I'm surprised at the responses. But, that's why I asked the question. I didn't think it was all that bad of an offer.

[NFL-ons]

Terrible

[Titans95]

These responses are very interesting.

Most ranking lists I can find have Kenyan Drake ahead or neck in neck in value with any of the other rookie RB's I'd be able to draft at 1.3.

Stafford, though not as good as Brady, is only 30 and a perennial good scoring QB. In most any ranking list I can find I see Stafford ranked ahead of Brady.

Then I'm getting a future 1st and some 2nd's this year just to add frosting.

I guess I'm surprised at the responses. But, that's why I asked the question. I didn't think it was all that bad of an offer.

I'm not sure what rankings you are looking at but Penny/Guice/Michel should all be much much higher ranked than Drake. Drake is the epitome of what a flash in the pan is. Drake flashed a lot of upside this past year but his job isn't automatically secured. Drake has never been in a bellcow role before in his entire football career including college. Even last year they wouldn't give him the full load while Damien Williams was healthy (who is terrible). I'm not saying its absolutely going to happen but it wouldn't surprise me 1 bit to see Kenyan Drake not be the starter by week 10. Next, I'd rather hang on to brady for 1-2 more years and get a QB with your 2nd round pick and let him develop. lastly a 2021 1st pick is utterly worthless.....thats 3 years away!! I get dynasty is all about the long game but trading anything past next years 1sts is just plain dumb.

[vixen]

Most ranking lists I can find have Kenyan Drake ahead or neck in neck in value with any of the other rookie RB's I'd be able to draft at 1.3.

Stafford, though not as good as Brady, is only 30 and a perennial good scoring QB. In most any ranking list I can find I see Stafford ranked ahead of Brady.

Then I'm getting a future 1st and some 2nd's this year just to add frosting.

I guess I'm surprised at the responses. But, that's why I asked the question. I didn't think it was all that bad of an offer.

are you looking at DLF?
Guice 14
Chubb 15
Penny 18
Sony 19
RoJo 22
Royce 25
Drake 27

i think it is a terrible offer... does that owner not have a 2019 1st or 2020 1st? 2021 is waaay too far away.. keep the pick, the 2021 is not likely early and as others have pointed out, mid/late 2nds in a 16 team league should be treated like 3rds...

[The Showstopper]

It makes me laugh when someone says..Drakes a flash in the pan, and his job isn’t secure this year...And then goes on to say how much more value a rookie who has NEVER played in the league is...I own Drake, and I believe in the talent I saw last year, I also understand the risk, but to say a guy like Guise or Penny is a MUCH better prospect then Drake is laughable...

[playa_hata]

It makes me laugh when someone says..Drakes a flash in the pan, and his job isn’t secure this year...And then goes on to say how much more value a rookie who has NEVER played in the league is...I own Drake, and I believe in the talent I saw last year, I also understand the risk, but to say a guy like Guise or Penny is a MUCH better prospect then Drake is laughable...

the homerism is make him delusional. bleep offer dont even think bout it.