Tyrell Williams or Donte Moncrief?

[Bot101]

Williams should have 75% of the votes even before Henry went down. This forum just can't quit Moncrief. There are WR drafted in the 1st round of the NFL Draft who have been given up on before Moncrief.

Seriously. When I read this thread earlier today Moncrief was winning by quite a bit. That’s just ridiculous to me.

[bruskie10]

Easily Williams for me. Tyrell will quietly put up points each year, while Moncreif will return to his usual form and disappear. I figure Moncrief will quickly slide down the Jax depth chart as the #4 WR by mid-season. Henry injury will only improve Williams success also.

[Goddard]

Agree that this has to be Williams.

[FantasyFreak]

Easily Williams for me. Tyrell will quietly put up points each year, while Moncreif will return to his usual form and disappear. I figure Moncrief will quickly slide down the Jax depth chart as the #4 WR by mid-season. Henry injury will only improve Williams success also.

I really don't think HH affects Tyrell that much. Henry's targets are mainly checkdowns, Tyrell is a down the field guy. Their targets don't really intersect. Rivers isn't going to heave it down the field twice as often because his starting TE is out. Whoever takes Henry's place at TE, and RB's, who operate closer to the line of scrimmage are much more likely to see any target increase people are talking about, IMO. I voted Williams, though, because I think he's better, with a better QB.

[CharlieKelly]

Williams should have 75% of the votes even before Henry went down. This forum just can't quit Moncrief. There are WR drafted in the 1st round of the NFL Draft who have been given up on before Moncrief.

Seriously. When I read this thread earlier today Moncrief was winning by quite a bit. That’s just ridiculous to me.

A lot of people have been holding onto Moncrief for years and will do anything to try and convince themselves that he's still got value.

[The.Big.Spank]

moncreif only cuz they signed him to way too much money and need to throw to him bunches to justify it. williams more appealing now that HH is done but i think that means more mike rather than more tyrell

this one for me. i am in the minority again.

[CharlieKelly]

moncreif only cuz they signed him to way too much money and need to throw to him bunches to justify it. williams more appealing now that HH is done but i think that means more mike rather than more tyrell

this one for me. i am in the minority again.

I wouldn't read into this too much. It's a 1 year deal and the Jags have had a ton of cap space to play with.

[The.Big.Spank]

True, but to me he has the highest upside and all the tools. His underperformance is a bit of a mystery. Such a hot and cold player, but he was 21,22,23 years old and Luck was hurt the last couple of years so i am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt on a question like this.