1.02 straight up for kennan Allen

[Prospector]

Allen - no hesitation

[Mephistopheles]

Rookie fever out of control.
This is Keenan 100%.
Only pick I'd consider for Keenan is 1.1

[M-Dub]

Only time of year where these posts exist.

Well to be fair, it’s the only time of year these posts can exist. We only know where a pick is actually slotted between the end of the fantasy season and the rookie draft. That said, I agree with most everyone. It’s Keenan by a significant margin.

Yeah, I thought of that as I typed. I left it. Kudos for you pointing it out, though. My point is people get worked up about it at this time of year, and I love Guice, but week 5, when Keenan is a WR1 and Guice most likely will not be destroying the league, I'm sure you could approach the Guice owner with Keenan and get plenty more back.

That’s a good point. I was only thinking about it in terms of future picks, not after the fact. Like, there’s no way anyone would trade Keenan for a single 1st during the season, no matter how likely that 1st looked to be a top 2 pick. But yeah, looking just at last year’s class, none of the top picks (Lenny, Davis, Mixon, CMC) have really skyrocketed in value.

[jessup45]

Only time of year where these posts exist.

Well to be fair, it’s the only time of year these posts can exist. We only know where a pick is actually slotted between the end of the fantasy season and the rookie draft. That said, I agree with most everyone. It’s Keenan by a significant margin.

Yeah, I thought of that as I typed. I left it. Kudos for you pointing it out, though. My point is people get worked up about it at this time of year, and I love Guice, but week 5, when Keenan is a WR1 and Guice most likely will not be destroying the league, I'm sure you could approach the Guice owner with Keenan and get plenty more back.

Agreed - KA by a lot