McKinnon++ for Mixon

[eraldo_coil]

I give: McKinnon, 1.10, Godwin

I receive: Joe Mixon

As expected, I've been hit up by multiple people in my league inquiring about McKinnon. One of the teams is a huge Niners homer, so i'm thinking this could be my chance to take advantage of McKinnon's inflated value and get something decent in return. I'm hoping to possibly get Mixon (who no one really seems to be talking about much right now), and lock down my RB starters a bit better.

Also, the opposing team already has Zeke, Kamara, Hyde, and 1.09 (not to mention Joe Williams, another guy he was overly high on because of the team) - so, definitely no shortage of RBs he can work with. He could also use some WR help, and Godwin is a nice young prospect that is generating some small buzz as of late.

Thoughts on this? Do I make a good case, or this still off in value?

[topher]

If you can get Mixon for that, that would be great, don’t see it getting done but I guess it depends on how much he wants McKinnon as a 49ers fan as you say.

[Titans95]

I feel like that is a fair offer even for someone who is unbiased and not a huge 49ers fan. I bet the deal gets done. He gets a Rb on his favorite team along with the WR and a 1.10 pick he can turn into anoter top WR rookie pick.

[GOTGDynasty]

I'm all in on Mixon. And you're right he is undervalued right now. I wouldn't let him go but many others would. Go for it.

[M-Dub]

I own all three players and like all three. Mixon is definitely the best piece in the deal, but that’s a pretty solid package to offer for him. Seems pretty fair to me.

[FKC]

IF you can get that done, do it NOW before McKinnon’s value disappears. His value will decline due to the draft.

[EAGLES]

That should get it done

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Meh, call me crazy but gimme McKinnon + 1.10.

[bsp27]

I'd honestly keep Mckinnon, 1.10 and Godwin

[keebs3]

Seems fair, I was thinking of offering a very similar deal. I was going to try and send McKinnon with Aaron Jones and the 2.04. But I have a feeling that won't do it.

[lukkynumber13]

I'll take Mixon for sure

[bsp27]

McKinnon is valued at about the 1.05-1.06, Godwin is about the 1.10-1.12, and then you have the 1.10 itself.

I love Mixon, but he is not worth essentially three firsts. That's pretty insane.

[lukkynumber13]

McKinnon is valued at about the 1.05-1.06, Godwin is about the 1.10-1.12, and then you have the 1.10 itself.

I love Mixon, but he is not worth essentially three firsts. That's pretty insane.

I don't think this would be a terrible return for Mixon, not at all, but your appraisals are quite generous.

McKinnon as the 1.05-6 is the absolute TOP-END of his possible value. Far from his typical value. The consensus on him would probably be 1.08-1.12.

Similarly with Godwin. I understand the case for him being valued as a late 1st, but you'd be hard pressed to trade him away for a 1st in most leagues.

[collbey]

Mixon. If you could get 1sts for McKinnon and Godwin, would jump all over that but don't see it happening.

[esloan35]

I'd honestly keep Mckinnon, 1.10 and Godwin

ditto.. McKinnon probably catches a easy 55-65 ppr passes by waking up.