POLL: Hunt + Mahomes + 5.2 OR McCaffrey + Garropolo + 6.5

[Snickers]

I was offered this trade. I have McCaffrey and 1.2 and 1.3 and 1.5. It's a 10 player keeper turned dynasty. 12-team league, 1 pt ppr.

I like McCaffrey ppr value, but not his long-term potential. Plus, I feel Norv Turner will do wonders with him. Hunt has a crowded backfield with Ware back and more offensive weapons. Mahomes has upside but is not proven. Some with Jimmy G. but he does have experience.

Please help me rationalize.

TEAM ONE IN SIGNATURE

[Goddard]

Hunt side.

[IR1]

Agree with Hunt side

[jnappy]

I actually like the CMC side, but I think it's close. Matter of preference.

[FoleysFolly]

First thoughts were give me the Hunt side, then thinking about it more I'd take the CMC side in part because I have no idea what Andy Reid is doing in KC stacking RBs but there is zero competition for CMC(all other things equal). Plus, JimmyG>Mahomes and I don't think the upgraded pick makes up for the loss on the other two.

Overall it's very close though so just a matter of opinion.

[vixen]

i will take the CMC side
i think CMC and Hunt are equal
i think Jimmy G > Mahomes
but i do think it is close

[keebs3]

I would take the Hunt side as well. Though it wouldn't break my heart if I had the McCaffrey side either... I think the potential of Mahomes swings it for me.

[diamonddave]

i like the hunt side. i think he's better than cmc now and in the future. i like jimmy a bit better than mahomes but wouldn't be sad if i had the pat. his upside seems higher with his legs.

[Snickers]

i like the hunt side. i think he's better than cmc now and in the future. i like jimmy a bit better than mahomes but wouldn't be sad if i had the pat. his upside seems higher with his legs.

I see this too, but in a ppr format, wouldn't CMC be the go to? While Hunt is hunkered down with a committee backfield. I do agree with Jimmy G and Mahomes.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

This is pretty even and comes down to preference.
Hunt = McCaffrey; Mahomes = Garoppolo

[skip]

Agreed this is preference. I'd go with whichever RB you prefer as I expect the QBs would be better as fantasy backups rather than starters. Both have potential for sure, I just wouldn't have the confidence in either to have them as my #1.