Mixon or Henry

[bot]

I am toying with acquiring Mixon and with the signing of Lewis I am open to moving Henry to do so. I think a trade like this comes down to personal preference, however I personally lean Mixon because of his pass catching ability. Curious what others think the gap might be?

[collbey]

Mixon for me. As you said personal preference.

[HughHoney]

I completely agree with your assessment. Since it can just be personal preference between the two, I would offer a straight swap but would be willing to add a 2nd if necessary.

[Cowboysfan33]

I completely agree with your assessment. Since it can just be personal preference between the two, I would offer a straight swap but would be willing to add a 2nd if necessary.

This for me too. I like Mixon more but not a first round difference so maybe a 2nd like Hugh said.

[stigskol]

Mixon.

[RB6]

Mixon. I'd add a 2nd to Henry to make it happen.

[Johnny Canuck]

Mixon. I'd add a 2nd to Henry to make it happen.

This for me as well. I'm usually more on the anti-mixon side of deals because I feel his value is artificially inflated by last years draft capital and overall hype...and gio simply running better than he did. But I'd still take Mixon over Henry, and would prob add a 2nd or 3rd to make it happen.

I like Henry but feel like Lewis is going to be the main back and Henry is going to be relegated to hammer status again. It's a shame, just wasting that kids talent.

[Goddard]

I like both, but I'd be willing to add a 2nd (or maybe even a late 1st) to get Mixon.

[Gtdano_14]

I'm in the camp that would pay Henry+ (up to an early 2nd) for Mixon also. As others have said, Mixon is more versatile between the two.

[jpusmc0311]

I don't think Lewis will take much from Henry's workload. He's a big and physical runner that has good durability, so he'll be a bellcow. Lewis should on take receiving downs, but Henry isn't much of a pass catcher anyways. I would still take Mixon over him, in a PPR, but not by a whole lot.

[Space Cowboy]

Close call but Mixon's pass catching chops puts him ahead of Henry.

[surgebird2]

Mixon easily, before and especially after the Lewis signing in TEN.

[Shoreline Steamers]

I like both, but I'd be willing to add a 2nd (or maybe even a late 1st) to get Mixon.

Was going to say this. Most are advocating for a 2nd, and that's where I'd start. But I don't see a whole lot of difference between a late 1st and an early 2nd in this draft. And if it lands you the RB you want, then it's not like you're giving up the farm to acquire him.

[Bad News Barrett]

Piling on for Mixon

[Ewilliams29]

mixon for me, would certainly add a pick 2 or 3rd to make it happen. Been trying to aquire mixon in two leagues and neither owner is interested in moving him. would take the shot now to get him