Too much for Mix?

[Big Tuna]

Went back and forth with offers. Comes to this
Give 1.04 + 2019 1st (projects late)
Get Joe Mixon

Team in sig

[Johnny Canuck]

the 1.04 and Mixon are equal. You'd be overpaying by adding the 1st. I can see adding a 2nd to just get the deal done - if you want him that bad, but anything more than the 1.04 is an overpayment to a varying degree.

No way I would add a 1st.

[Goddard]

I prefer Mixon to the 1.02, so a late 1st doesn't do much for me here.

[Checker1183]

the 1.04 and Mixon are equal. You'd be overpaying by adding the 1st. I can see adding a 2nd to just get the deal done - if you want him that bad, but anything more than the 1.04 is an overpayment to a varying degree.

No way I would add a 1st.

100%

[RB6]

The 2019 1st is a little rich. Try with a 2nd.

[skip]

Agreed with the majority here that Mixon's value is pretty close to the 1.04 and an additional 1st is too much. I wouldn't mind adding a 2019 2nd round pick but not a 1st.

[Big Tuna]

I sent these offers before posting:
Mixon for 1.04, his counter was Mixon 1.04 + '19 1st
Mixon for 1.04 + '19 2nd, rejected
Mixon for 1.04 + '19 2nd + '19 3rd, rejected

Honestly thought the original offer of 1.04 for Mixon was completely fair

[Johnny Canuck]

I sent these offers before posting:
Mixon for 1.04, his counter was Mixon 1.04 + '19 1st
Mixon for 1.04 + '19 2nd, rejected
Mixon for 1.04 + '19 2nd + '19 3rd, rejected

Honestly thought the original offer of 1.04 for Mixon was completely fair

Sometimes the best deal you do is the one you don't make...don't overpay. Your offers are more than fair, he's obvs a Mixon truther, which is fine, but it likely means you can't get him without overpaying.

[HWfloss]

Yeah, I think 1.4 and a 2nd is fair. Probably wouldn't go beyond that.

[Shoreline Steamers]

I sent these offers before posting:
Mixon for 1.04, his counter was Mixon 1.04 + '19 1st
Mixon for 1.04 + '19 2nd, rejected
Mixon for 1.04 + '19 2nd + '19 3rd, rejected

Honestly thought the original offer of 1.04 for Mixon was completely fair

Sometimes the best deal you do is the one you don't make...don't overpay. Your offers are more than fair, he's obvs a Mixon truther, which is fine, but it likely means you can't get him without overpaying.

Bingo.

It sounds like you're not getting Mixon. Your offers were plenty fair, and he's not budging off that 2019 1st.

[Favrezilla]

I prefer Mixon to the 1.02, so a late 1st doesn't do much for me here.

Me too...I'm really surprised at the poll. Hope all these Mixon detractors will own up to it this season

[murphysxm]

I think Mixon is less than the 1.04 for me at this point. Just was not impressed. Cristine Michael 2.0?

[BradysBunch]

As a mixon owner, I think I would take 1.4 and the late first. I would not take the other offers with a 2nd/3rd.

[lukkynumber13]

Mixon side for me.

[kadun2]

Mixon side as well