Davonta Freeman vs Corey Davis

[sjwill]

Which side needs to add and how much?

[Titans95]

I voted even because it really comes down to each team's needs.

[ThePeckers]

Davis hasn't proven much yet, but I do like the possibility that he'll be a decent pro for some years to come. Based on immediate production, Davis by a little.

[jpusmc0311]

I always go with the proven player. I think Davis has the potential of being a solid WR1, but until then, I chose "freeman by a little".

[RB6]

Freeman if competing. Davis if rebuilding.

[Johnny Canuck]

Davis has shown very little. Based on last yr I'd be happy if he turned out to be a WR2, and have strong reservations about him ever becoming a WR1.

Given the scarcity of RBs and Freeman's production history (NMT Coleman being out of town in one yr), I would take the Freeman side by a mile. I'm pretty surprised it's all that close tbh. No way should it be a one for one.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I voted even because it really comes down to each team's needs.

x2

[Goddard]

I think their values are pretty close, with maybe a slight edge to Freeman because of proven production. However, I can see someone going with Davis if they needed a WR or were rebuilding.

[Bisquiteen Trisket]

Freeman side by a lot. Consistent RB1, even when in a time share. Most people talk about Coleman’s value going up when/if he leaves ATL next year. The big news there for me is that Freeman gets a bump in touches too. He’s locked into that offense.

Davis finished the year with a strong, nationally televised game. That’s literally all he did this year. He was an injured rookie, so he gets a pass for the most part. But by no means should he be anywhere close to Freeman value-wise. His value is pure speculation at this point.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

voting is all over the place lol