Jacksonville Defense Trade...

[Chris10385]

Got offered Minnesota Defense and Matt Ryan for my Jacksonville Defense. Current QB's are Alex Smith and I'll count Case Keenum. Take it?

[FantasyFreak]

What are the scoring rules for D? If it's standard I would take it. Minnesota's D is no slouch, and Ryan may be your best option at QB this year, and is a few years younger than Smith, so it gives you more time to find a replacement, PLUS it gives you the option of playing Ryan or Smith depending on matchups.

[Chris10385]

Fumble Recoveries 1-99 5 point for every 1
Interceptions Caught 1-99 6 point for every 1
Blocked Field Goals 1-99 15 point for every 1
Blocked Punts 1-99 15 point for every 1
Blocked Extra Points 1-99 15 point for every 1
Sacked a QB 0-99 3 point for every 1
Safeties 1-99 15 point for every 1
Total Points Allowed 0-0 20
Total Points Allowed 1-6 15
Total Points Allowed 7-13 10
Total Points Allowed 14-20 5
Total Points Allowed 21-27 0
Total Points Allowed 28-34 -5
Total Points Allowed 35-41 -10
Total Points Allowed 42-48 -15
Total Points Allowed 49-99 -20
Defensive & Special Teams TDs1-99 1-99 10 point for every 1

[Chris10385]

Definitely not standard scoring...

[FantasyFreak]

What was the total score of both Jax and Min last year? Divide that by 17 for your PPG difference, then factor whether you feel that will be repeated, and if it's worth the difference of Ryan to you. I'd still go with Ryan and Minny, based on the fact that Minnesota should have a strong D for a while as well. I would expect Ryan to put up better numbers this year, and Smith to regress in Washington.

[Chris10385]

What was the total score of both Jax and Min last year? Divide that by 17 for your PPG difference, then factor whether you feel that will be repeated, and if it's worth the difference of Ryan to you. I'd still go with Ryan and Minny, based on the fact that Minnesota should have a strong D for a while as well. I would expect Ryan to put up better numbers this year, and Smith to regress in Washington.

Jags - 535
Vikes - 339

[FantasyFreak]

What was the total score of both Jax and Min last year? Divide that by 17 for your PPG difference, then factor whether you feel that will be repeated, and if it's worth the difference of Ryan to you. I'd still go with Ryan and Minny, based on the fact that Minnesota should have a strong D for a while as well. I would expect Ryan to put up better numbers this year, and Smith to regress in Washington.

Jags - 535
Vikes - 339

That's over 10 points a game difference. That's a tough one. Jags scored 7 TD's, Vikings 1. Those numbers can jump around from year to year, but this is a tough call..

[Space Cowboy]

You need to post full defensive rankings to get a full perspective. Anyway you need QB help.

[skip]

Defensive scoring is way too volitle year to year. Give me whichever side has other pieces.

[AresGodOWar]

Keep the Jac D Ryan is just a mid level QB I would rather start Smith every week

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Defensive scoring is way too volitle year to year. Give me whichever side has other pieces.

x2. Both are good defenses, and defensive / return TDs are fluky.

[MichaelScarn]

Keep JAX, Ryan is meh without Kyle Shanahan.

[stoneghost28]

I'd rather keep Jacksonville. ryan has been awful two of the past three years. Jacksonville's D is young and the vast majority of the talent is in place for multiple years. I'd rather have Jack D unless someone is shocking me w/a major overpay (and I too have no idea what is fair value in pick(s) for my Jacksonville D).

[vixen]

MN D just got better with the addition of Richardson... you could use another QB as insurance....i would take MN D side
WARNING: A MINNESOTA VIKINGS FAN IN THE HOUSE