1.01 or Landry++

[The Fantasy Feud]

For team 2 in sig. I have won the league 3 years ina row and wanna change thinsg up a bit. Im a big Giants fan and would love nothing more then to get Saquan, especially if he goes to NY. I made the following offer and cant tell if I am overpaying, if it is fair, or if I need to up it to have a chance. He has another offer from my biggest competitor of Corey Davis, 1.2, and a 2020 first

My offer:

Give: Landry, Shephard, Hyde, 2020 First, 3 second rounders.

Get: Saquan

Thoughts?

[bronx]

Huge Giants fan, as well, but putting that aside, nothing about your offer really entices me.

Are the 2nd round picks even this year? I'm not even moving Hyde for 2020 picks, so Barkley is out of the question.

I may be falling for hype, but I think there needs to be more immediate value.

[joeya2001]

pass

[Goddard]

I wouldn't give that for the 1.01, but I also wouldn't expect it to get accepted.

[JJRules]

Doesn't seem remotely close unless the other guy is in a complete rebuild, and even then it's probably light.

[Nightmares]

I think I would take your competitor's offer if I was the 1.1 owner. Davis, 1.2 and a 2020 1st is pretty solid.

[jonf86]

I don't think your offer is bad or a massive overpay, but I'd prefer the competitors offer if I have the choice

[EAGLES]

Agree with the others. Your offer is not as good as the competitor’s offer. You’ll have to switch it up or stay put (which isn’t a bad thing considering you’ve won the ‘ship 3 years in a row ).

[Bay City Original]

As an owner of the 1.01 pick, I'd prefer the other offer much more than your's... though your offer is fine, in terms of value.

If I were to trade 1.01 for a package similar to what you're offering, I'd probably be in a rebuild mode and Hyde would do nothing for me and the direction of my team.