Dalvin for Mixon and 1.11

[dynastyaggie]

.5 ppr. Been offered my Dalvin for Mixon and 1.11 rookie pick. Leaning toward accepting, but wanted to pop in here and get some opinions. TIA.

[NoFlyZone]

I like mixon more than cook straight up. Ill probably be in the minority here but 11 should bridge any gap between the two.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

I know that in this forum many guys love mixon, but I lean cook I think you showed last year that hes the lead dog in this backfield, with cousins in there he should be fine

[RB6]

Mixon side.

[RoyalDynasty]

Mixon > Cook The 11th overall is a bonus.
Mixon could have gone number one last year without his domestic dispute issue and would be #2 this year behind Barkley. He was not giving the reins last year but this year he will be the work horse with an improved O line. Mixon side all day.

[Gtdano_14]

haha, I wonder which way this poll will go in this site.

[hockeyBjj]

This all depends on your personal opinion of the players. Many see them equal, some see either Cook or Mixon slightly ahead of the other. No one is wrong unless they're trying to say its a large gap between them, regardless of who they like more

This is up to you. I think Cook will have the better 2018 season based on being on a better team (The exact opposite thing we said when we cried about him being drafted by the Vikings last year lol) but after that it's a crap shoot. Out of college most believed Mixon the more talented back, but in the 3 games we saw him Cook looked the best back of the class

Small sample size. Who knows. Flip a coin, or go the side of the bonus late first

[honcho55]

I've got cook and mixon pretty close, so it's a easy side for me.

[Goddard]

There shouldn't be much of a gap in value between the two players, if any. I actually prefer Mixon by a small amount. Regardless, there shouldn't have to be a 1st added to either side.

[RAB]

Cook has the better talent and the better situation. Assuming health, Cook pretty easily

[EAGLES]

Tough call. Small sample size on Cook and an injured ACL, but looked great in that small sample size. I’d lean keeping Cook given his team and what I saw between him and Mixon

[topher]

Man, this is close, I voted Mixon because of the pick and that I think he has more upside than Cook.

[Trevormortis]

Mixon for me. Worried about Cook holding up and being dependent on big holes to gain any yards.

[surgebird2]

Toss up for me, but I voted Mixon and the pick. I liked Mixon more coming out, but Dalvin was not far behind him and showed really well, so I could see someone taking either side.

[The Red Rooster]

If you want to make a trade on value, I think it's the side with the pick. But I think the Cook side has the best individual piece to help you win fantasy matchups.