Keelan Cole or Sterling Shepard?

[Space Cowboy]

What's the gap between these two if any?

[heldlightning]

I'd offer a mid second to move from Cole to Shepard, but I'd probably want an early 2nd / late first to give up Shepard

[Goddard]

I'd offer a mid second to move from Cole to Shepard, but I'd probably want an early 2nd / late first to give up Shepard

Pretty much this.

[Crwdstunna]

I wouldn’t say the gap is that much, but it’s close. I’d say the gap is a late 2nd especially with the depth of this class.

[skiptomybru]

I recently bought Shepard for my 2.01 (17) and 3.01 (33) in a 16 team league. Felt like that was a fair deal if that helps at all. I don’t think Cole holds the same value as Shep. Although I can see a spike in his value right now with the uncertainty of Lee and Robinson returning. Target share looks favorable moving forward.

[1coldone]

I'd offer a mid second to move from Cole to Shepard, but I'd probably want an early 2nd / late first to give up Shepard

This sounds about right to me, as well.

[Heartwork]

I was offered 2.10 in my league for Shepard. Is that to lite?

[1coldone]

I was offered 2.10 in my league for Shepard. Is that to lite?

I would not trade shepard for the 2.10, myself.

[JetsFan86]

I'd need more to move step for Cole also.

[skip]

I was offered 2.10 in my league for Shepard. Is that to lite?

I wouldn't take that pick if you included Cole with it.

[saw061600]

I was offered 2.10 in my league for Shepard. Is that to lite?

That offer is insulting.

[Heartwork]

I was offered 2.04 for him now. I don't know how I feel about him in general. I think he could be good but could easily see 3 targets a game with OBJ, Engram and possibly a RB from the draft.

[Big Al]

Shepard is worth way more than the 2.10 or Cole. I agree with Skip, I wouldn't move Shepard for both of them.

[HawkeyeState]

To be honest, Keelan Cole is barely more than waiver wire fodder for me. Shep has production in the NFL, NFL draft pedigree, and college production at a good school to boost his profile. He’s worth more than his ADP is right now

[RB6]

Shepard pretty easily over Cole. I'd need at least an early 2nd to consider it.