Doctson/1.02 vs Thielen/1.07 *Poll*

[Bot101]

Offer on the table.

Give 1.02 + Josh Doctson

Get 1.07 + Adam Thielen


Team in sig.

[jdomer2403]

Give me thielen and 1.7. I believe thielen is superior to Doctson and 5 picks to get to Guice doesn’t cover the value change. 1.7 is still a great pick (ridley, Washington, Chubb range)

[HughHoney]

Thielen>>>Doctson. That difference is greater than the difference in the pics. Put another way, the difference in 1.07 and Doctson is greater than the difference in 1.02 and Thielen.

[jcc1964]

Definitely Thielen + 1.07. You already have the 1.01 which will give you Barkley to go with Mixon at RB. You could use another stud WR since you start three in your league and could put two more WR at the flex position. Doctson seems like a risk and not overwhelmed with any player you can get with the 1.02 compared to the 1.07.

[Farley]

Prefer the 1.02 and Doctson side by quite a bit.

I'd consider the trade without Doctson so think he's a nice bonus.

[RightlegTucker]

Really depends on how you feel about Guice in comparison to the rest of the mid 1st RBs. If you don't think there's a big gap I'd go with the Thielen side, if you think Guice is 1B I'd take the 1.02.

[cornhole2412]

Thielen is the safer bet at WR today, but I think Doctsons ceiling is higher and he's has youth on his side. Keeping 1.02 also potentially gives you 3 top 25 RB's under the age of 22

[Needalife]

No brainer for me. I take Thielen side as I think it nets you 2 startable assets vs 1. Thielen's a young ppr stud (15 ppg, 11th overall). Doctson has some potential but I'm not sure Alex Smith will bring it to the fore. The 1.02 is a nice pick but it's not Barkley and this year's class is pretty deep where 1.07 is going to have a lot of value as well. Plus, I'm lukewarm on Guice, Ridley and Sutton. 1.07..... Barkley, Guice, Ridley, Sutton, Sony, Ronald Jones, Chubb, Kirk plus the QBs. Pretty good 1.07 if you ask me.

[snaps06]

I like 1.02 and Doctson. I think Theilen is a sell-high right now, and Doctson is a buy-low. I can see Doctson having more value by this point next year.

[Bot101]

Well we settled. He wants to compete for a title and thus didnt want to sell Thielen. Final trade is

Give: Doctson + 2. 01

Get: 1.07 + J Stew

[snaps06]

Well we settled. He wants to compete for a title and thus didnt want to sell Thielen. Final trade is

Give: Doctson + 2. 01

Get: 1.07 + J Stew

Not bad. I like that trade for you.

[Bot101]

Well we settled. He wants to compete for a title and thus didnt want to sell Thielen. Final trade is

Give: Doctson + 2. 01

Get: 1.07 + J Stew

Not bad. I like that trade for you.

Well hopefully Doctson continues his path of disappointment. Ive really liked what I've seen from the players going in that range.

[BigBawseRoss]

take it! Guice will have more value than either thielen or doctson

[Bot101]

take it! Guice will have more value than either thielen or doctson

We made a slightly dif trade. Scroll up a bit.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Well we settled. He wants to compete for a title and thus didnt want to sell Thielen. Final trade is
Give: Doctson + 2. 01
Get: 1.07 + J Stew

I like this.