12 team ppr dynasty: Hunter Henry and 3.1 for 1.11, Moncreif, Kevin White, 4.11

[sconnie21]

Which side do you prefer based just on value alone? I'd be getting the Henry side. Thanks!

[bjd5211]

For me Henry > 1.11 the rest is a bunch of irrelevant garbage, I would definitely do that deal

[thomasscheeks]

Henry easily

[TheEastWest]

Henry without question .. He worth more 1.11 and some roster cloggers

[vixen]

Henry for me too...

[dmac37]

Also say Henry

[Edgy68]

Henry is worth at least that late 1st, probably closer to 1.04-1.06. Someone mentioned roster cloggers, so you have to factor in the value of open spots that can be used to pick up players who actually could show some value. This trade should be accepted soon.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

henry

[Petrolbomber]

Henry side. Moncrief is a nice add if he pulls it together. The 4.11, if you use it, is a huge dart throw. As someone else mentioned, I hope you are not clogging a spot to hold White. A nice free piece if he can be what he was drafted for.

[crip7300]

I will play the contrarian here. The value is on the 1.11 side. Henry is currently valued around the 1.8-1.10. But if either Moncrief (only 24) or White (25) pull it together next season for even a WR2 season, either becomes worth at least a 2nd rounder, if not a late 1st value wise and currently I would think you could get a late 2nd/early 3rd for Moncrief and a 3rd or 4th for White right now.

[skip]

I can see the justifications for both sides of this deal. I agree that Henry's value is not in the top half of the first round and much closer to the 1.11 but slightly more valuable. The only piece on the other side otherwise that has any potential value to me would be Moncrief. But I am also not that much of a believer. At this moment I do think the Henry side has the slight Advantage but the potential is certainly there to swing this the other way.