Arob vs. Adams

[BelichekYourSelf]

Adams easily for me... Rodgers vs. Bortles is a huge difference.

[Vcize]

I love ARob but no one is taking him coming off an ACL over Adams. Even if you prefer Robinson as a player you take Adams for value. Obvious answer.

Adams has concussion issues which in this day and age is probably more scary than a single clean knee injury.

I still take Adams, but his concussions are being overlooked here. He had 3 concussions in 14 calendar months. That's Jordan Reed levels.

[Cowboysfan33]

I remember last off-season when so many on this forum were very low on Adams. Anyway, a lot changes in dynasty leagues, in one season. I would take Adams now over AROB but I don’t think it’s a huge gap. Mainly, imo, it’s getting a seemingly “safer” player in Adams or going for the upside in AROB. It all kinda depends on whether you like to gamble or not.

[HughHoney]

Adams is safer but I don’t see his ceiling being too much higher than what we’ve seen. I think GB will continue to spread the ball around and Adams will be good for around 80 catches and 1000 yards. Hopefully he will continue to produce in the red zone with 10-12 TDs. So far he’s yet to have a 1000 yard season or more than 75 catches. ARob has a higher ceiling I think but more risk.

[Vcize]

I guess I'll just sit here and watch as people call a guy who just had the same number of concussions as CJ Fiedorowicz (who is likely going to retire because of his concussions) over the last year and a half "safe".

[PercyR1]

A.rob lower floor higher ceiling
Adams higher floor lower ceiling

Reverse teams we would all be saucing in our mouths with a.rob on greenbay
Adams on Jags we would not even blink an eye.

Give me the more elite talent 100% of the time and thats a WR who put up a monster season with a sub par QB - A.rob all day baby

[moishetreats]

Not all concussions are the same. Just look at games missed (and Adams could have come back for the last two weeks of the season, but, clearly, there was no point).

[Bot101]

In a vacuum Arob. But Adams has Rodgers and Arob has Bortles. That taken into account, Adams.

[drbuttermaker]

A.rob lower floor higher ceiling
Adams higher floor lower ceiling

Reverse teams we would all be saucing in our mouths with a.rob on greenbay
Adams on Jags we would not even blink an eye.

Give me the more elite talent 100% of the time and thats a WR who put up a monster season with a sub par QB - A.rob all day baby

Thanks for saving me the time of typing that.

[HughHoney]

A.rob lower floor higher ceiling
Adams higher floor lower ceiling

Reverse teams we would all be saucing in our mouths with a.rob on greenbay
Adams on Jags we would not even blink an eye.

Give me the more elite talent 100% of the time and thats a WR who put up a monster season with a sub par QB - A.rob all day baby

Remember though, that season Jax was awful and always playing from behind. A lot of that was garbage time stats that wouldn’t have been there last year. I like ARob and think he has a very high ceiling but I’d like to see where he lands. It could be back in Jax but now with a great defense on a run first team that still has that subpar QB. If so, I would temper my expectations for another monster season.

[Vcize]

When I looked at the numbers ARob's garbage time stats weren't actually as big a part as I was expecting in his 2015 season. He only had 15 receptions for 240 yards when trailing by 9+ points. Granted he did have 6 TDs on those 15 catches but that still leaves 65-1160-8 when they were leading, tied, or within one score.

[HughHoney]

When I looked at the numbers ARob's garbage time stats weren't actually as big a part as I was expecting in his 2015 season. He only had 15 receptions for 240 yards when trailing by 9+ points. Granted he did have 6 TDs on those 15 catches but that still leaves 65-1160-8 when they were leading, tied, or within one score.

Me either, good to know. I owned him that year in a redraft but it was TD heavy. Maybe that’s why I remember it that way.

[Thurston4040]

Adams

[1coldone]

adams, arob could fall...he did for me...team 2