Carr or Winston and Alshon for Rodgers?

[joeday]

In a 12 team, PPR league would you trade Aaron Rodgers for Derek Carr or Jameis Winston and Alshon Jeffery?

Here is my team:
QBs -- Rodgers, Brees, Big Ben, Foles
RBs -- Gurley, Dion Lewis, Barber, Mal.Brown, Dunbar, Martin, Quizz, JWhite, Woodhead
WRs -- Gordon, AJG, Julio, Dem, MLee, Jordy, PRichardson, ESanders
TEs - Gronk, GCelek, Gates, RSJ, Shaheen
2018 Picks -- none (lol)

[hockeyBjj]

I would take the downgrade from Rodgers to Carr for ASJ considering you have Brees. see if you can get him to add a 2nd to at least roll the dice on a rookie once lol

[jwb32]

With those WRs, you have to go for it now. Keep Rodgers if you think you can contend. If you don't think you can get there, I think it's fine moving Rodgers.....though I'd move Jordy, Sanders, DT, Gronk, AJG first as their value is falling off a cliff (AJG not so much but soon).

[RB6]

I'd take Winston and Alshon.