Kupp vs. Godwin

[joekuhns11]

In a vacuum who do you take here?

[BradysBunch]

I own both. I would keep Godwin if I had to choose. I know Kupp did pretty well last year, but when Godwin becomes the true #2 opposite Evans, I will take him.

[RB6]

Godwin.

[HughHoney]

I own and like both players. Kupp has the higher floor while Godwin has the higher ceiling although Kupp’s is solid in ppr. To me they’re about equal and both worth a late 1st.

[jwb32]

I'd gamble with Godwin's potential upside......though Kupp's safer floor might make more sense for some teams.

[keller569]

I have neither but am interested in both. I'd be willing to pay a slightly more for Godwin based on his upside and fewer mouths to feed in TB

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Kupp. Bird in the hand here. I like Godwin, but I think Kupp's 2017 production is about Godwin's best cast scenario anyway, so why not just take Kupp? Also, Sean McVay > Dirk Koetter.

[kamihamster]

Kupp. Bird in the hand here. I like Godwin, but I think Kupp's 2017 production is about Godwin's best cast scenario anyway, so why not just take Kupp? Also, Sean McVay > Dirk Koetter.

x2

[Favrezilla]

Kupp by a mile IMO, at best Godwin might become the 2nd option, but my guess is he will always vie for targets with OJ/Brate and the Slot guy AND i fully expect TB to go after a RB in the next draft or 2.

kupp has shown to be not only a very effective chain mover and 3rd conversion safety blanket but a reasonable redzone threat as well

[jeffster]

Kupp. Bird in the hand here. I like Godwin, but I think Kupp's 2017 production is about Godwin's best cast scenario anyway, so why not just take Kupp? Also, Sean McVay > Dirk Koetter.

x2

x3. Godwin is talented, but Kupp feels like the next Doug Baldwin. Low WR1, high WR2 performance that never quite gets reflected in his price because he's not sexy enough.

[The.Big.Spank]

I own and like both players. Kupp has the higher floor while Godwin has the higher ceiling although Kupp’s is solid in ppr. To me they’re about equal and both worth a late 1st.

This

[ddog2303]

Kupp for me.

[jpusmc0311]

I like Kupp more.

[spartan833]

Kupp, not close imo. I would need 2nd round value with Godwin for Kupp.

[Wsn21]

Id take kupp pretty easily, imagine kupps role if sammy leaves eventually)+ Goff maturing more