Trade offer/need help; Antonio Brown for Cooper, Hunt and 1.09?

[bob b]

What do you think? We need a top end WR to get us to the promised land; We would recieve Antonio Brown and AP (yuk) ang give up Amari Cooper, Kareem Hunt and our 1.09.

Thoughts please...

[snaps06]

You are overpaying by at least a 1st round of value. This is a major sell-low on Cooper. Hunt +1.09 sounds about right IMO.

[crip7300]

I love Antonio but he is about to turn 30, not saying he doesn't have some good years left but that seems like too much value and youth to give up. I think either player and the 1.9 would be about right, but most AB owners are probably wanting an overpay, so if you really want him, you might have to pay that, I personally wouldn't.

[Riders4Ever]

Agree with the others that the offer is an overpay for Brown. Could you get something of value rather than AP?

[bob b]

Agree with the others that the offer is an overpay for Brown. Could you get something of value rather than AP?

He doesn't have alot of talent on his roster...nothing we would want or he would give up: we countered with the following two offers and both were rejected;

Counter #1; Brown and AP for Hunt, Cooper and 2.07

Counter #2; Brown and AP for Hunt, Mike Williams and 1.09

As I said, both were rejected

[flyersfan1981]

Agree with the others that the offer is an overpay for Brown. Could you get something of value rather than AP?

He doesn't have alot of talent on his roster...nothing we would want or he would give up: we countered with the following two offers and both were rejected;

Counter #1; Brown and AP for Hunt, Cooper and 2.07

Counter #2; Brown and AP for Hunt, Mike Williams and 1.09

As I said, both were rejected

Then the guy is an idiot and we know why his team is devoid of any talent. I wouldn't pay that for Brown, move on if Counter #1 isn't enough.

[ManhattanProject]

Counter #1 should have been more than enough. I'd count your blessings it wasn't taken and move on to another trade partner. Giving up a haul like that should get you a top wr from another team maybe even obj if they are a cooper believer.

[snaps06]

Jeez, definitely time to move on from that guy. You can get a very serviceable WR for way less than what he is demanding.

[jeaton6]

Agree with all others your counters were still overpays.move on.

[Goddard]

Go after Hopkins or OBJ if you're willing to give up that much.

[Rams Fan]

As a OBJ owner I would accept that deal quite easily. To much value to pass up on.

[Titans95]

At this point I feel like its very counter productive to consider trading Cooper. A year ago he was a top 5 WR asset, I think your better off holding on to him and hoping he rebounds. Also you've got some solid young receivers in Corey Davis and Mike Williams that I think you could easily have a solid crew in the next year or so.

[bob b]

Go after Hopkins or OBJ if you're willing to give up that much.

the Antonio Brown owner also owns ODB..so I am guessing he would want a king's ransom for him as well...

[bob b]

At this point I feel like its very counter productive to consider trading Cooper. A year ago he was a top 5 WR asset, I think your better off holding on to him and hoping he rebounds. Also you've got some solid young receivers in Corey Davis and Mike Williams that I think you could easily have a solid crew in the next year or so.

yes, you may be right...my co-owner and I wanted Brown to get us over the top...we underperformed this year due to Rodgers, Allen Robinson and David Johnson injuries and wanted a top WR as that is our weakness at the moment, but all of those you mentioned could become elite...

[bob b]

Go after Hopkins or OBJ if you're willing to give up that much.

the Brown owner also owns OBJ and the Hopkins owner just won our super bowl and never trades