Potential Gurley Trade

[keller569]

I was having a few beers with a buddy and he mentioned that he wanted Gurley. We started talking and this is where we got. There's no official offer, but I will continue the talks tomorrow. Just wanted everyone thoughts.

Give: Gurley
Get: Hilton, D. Cook, 1.04

Seems like pretty great value to me, but curious to everyone's opinions.

[Checker1183]

I like It. 3 very nice pieces there

[Goddard]

I'd take it as well, but it's pretty close.

[saw061600]

Like the pieces but mostly because I can't believe Gurley doesn't regress some. I mean, really, he can't possibly put up those points again...can he?

[darewood11]

I like cook a lot and if luck is back to 100 percent I think that's a good deal. I also agree Gurley has to regress a little I'd think

[Gator Sens]

I would take the deal. 3 good pieces moving back.

[Cowboysfan33]

Yeah, I agree with others, if I was ever going to trade Gurley, that would probably do it.

[Mustachio]

I think the extreme lack of safety is not being addressed here. Cook is competing with two proven and very solid backs + possibly injury prone, Andew Luck is a roll of the dice and the Colts are definitely going to add a WR. That leaves you with the 1.04, which translates to his #2 back. I will concede that it's close.

[mclilj]

I'd probably hold gurley

[Thurston4040]

I'd take the Cook side, but I'm a big believer in Cook's talent.

[Phaded]

Cook is competing with two proven and very solid backs + possibly injury prone,

lol What?
McKinnon is an FA and is as good as gone.
Latavius is JAG and you could say even more injury prone..

Anyhow, that is a good haul for Gurley.

[1coldone]

Have to go with the pieces, though...as a Gurley owner it would be difficult to let him go...lol