Andrew Luck Offers (POLL UPDATED)

[Golly Dagger]

I'm in a rebuild, and I'm wondering, are these offers too low for Luck?

Team 1 in Sig:

Goff and Ravens D for Luck

Dak for Luck (update)



I love Goff and love everything about the Rams offense right now, but is he truly the talent Luck is?
How concerned are you with Luck's health?

Thanks in advance!

[NoFlyZone]

It seems low to me, but after Josh McDaniels backed out of the HC offer for the Colts, I instantly wondered if Lucks health had something to do with it. I don't know if I could trade him for Goff though.

[NoFlyZone]

Also, if you're looking to trade luck I look elsewhere, like a rb or a wr upgrade because a defense doesn't do much for you and Stafford will start over Goff 70 or more percent of the time

[Golly Dagger]

It seems low to me, but after Josh McDaniels backed out of the HC offer for the Colts, I instantly wondered if Lucks health had something to do with it. I don't know if I could trade him for Goff though.

Yeah I was wondering that as well. I've heard a variety of things, but that is a definite possibility. I've tried selling Luck for about a month now but received either extremely low ball offers or none at all. This is the best one so far.

[Golly Dagger]

Also, if you're looking to trade luck I look elsewhere, like a rb or a wr upgrade because a defense doesn't do much for you and Stafford will start over Goff 70 or more percent of the time

True that, although I'm pushing to move Stafford as well, but that point about the defense is true.

[PigskinAddict]

Andrew Luck's latest injury news
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... o-throwing

[Blueboy]

This is definitely a buy-low offer due to the McDaniels scare. It comes down to whether or not you believe the recent news about his health improvements... it seems like there was intentionally misleading positive information about Luck prior to this, and the way the Colts have handled this has been very strange.

I think Luck will be alright next year. If you don't think he will, this isn't a terrible buy-low.

[Golly Dagger]

This is definitely a buy-low offer due to the McDaniels scare. It comes down to whether or not you believe the recent news about his health improvements... it seems like there was intentionally misleading positive information about Luck prior to this, and the way the Colts have handled this has been very strange.

I think Luck will be alright next year. If you don't think he will, this isn't a terrible buy-low.

Yeah, I have no idea how to feel about Luck. My gut says he'll be fine, but my gut said that over and over and over again last season as well haha.

[lukkynumber13]

I love Goff and love everything about the Rams offense right now, but is he truly the talent Luck is?

No, Goff isn't in the same ballpark as Luck for talent. But obviously that doesn't always matter hugely in fantasy, PLUS when you factor in the health risk for Luck and the age difference, I understand the pull for the Goff side. I still choose luck fairly easily, however.

[RightlegTucker]

If Luck's healthy this isn't close. I'd rather hold and hope he can come back. From your perspective I'd do this 10/10 times, doubt he accepts the Ravens D though.

[Golly Dagger]

So another owner caught wind of the trade and is offering Dak for Luck.

[Goddard]

Goff's talent is no where near Luck's. If you're scared of Luck's injury, I guess it's not a terrible return, but I'd personally pass.

[LondonMonarchs]

If you are in a rebuild there is little value moving Luck in a 1:1 trade. You have to hold right now.

I sold him hight last summer (SF) for a package that included Wentz, Miller, Enunwa, 2nd (I think there was something else in therr too). I may have got lucky with Wentz.

[esloan35]

I like Goff and another player or pick. The D is like vanilla ice cream at this point. With the news yesterday its going to be really hard until he hits the field again.

[IR1]

The Goff deal isn't bad. I'm holding and hoping once news gets out that he's throwing, his value will go up.