Poll: which side? Kamara for mixon plus

[dchurch85]

For team 1 in sig.

I give Kamara
I get mixon, 1.09, 2019 1st (likely top 5)

[Tyrober]

I love Kamara but there is a decent chance Mixon could be just as good next year if not better. Give me Mixon + 1.09 and another first with ease.

[dirtyjohnnie]

Mixon side for me and it is not even close. I hope that is an actual offer you have received!

[jwb32]

Mixon easily.....that's an overpay by one of the 1sts.

[ArrylT]

Both Shredder and Splinter are in agreement that this is a cowabunga good deal for you.

[dchurch85]

Hahaha he came back and said no Mixon, just the 1.09 and 19 1st

[ArrylT]

Hahaha he came back and said no Mixon, just the 1.09 and 19 1st

His first will not likely be as early as projected if Kamara puts up similar production in 2018 (and Mixon takes a Melvin Gordon type step up in Year 2), and I was happy to snap up Kamara at 1.09 in drafts this past off-season, so you should ninja-chop your way to the reject button.

[Phaded]

Hahaha he came back and said no Mixon, just the 1.09 and 19 1st

I own both Kamara & Mixon in one league..
I think there is a sizeable gap between the two.

I would not give up Kamara for those 2 picks.
However, with the Mixon + picks, if he puts it back on the table I would probably take that.

[topher]

Hahaha he came back and said no Mixon, just the 1.09 and 19 1st

Damn, that OP deal was pretty good, this not so much. If he keeps Mixon that pick gets worse. Easy pass.

[The.Big.Spank]

I would be willing to get there will be some regression in Kamara and I still don't see him as a workhorse back.

[vixen]

hard pass on the deal without Mixon

[Blueboy]

With Mixon, that was an absolute steal. With just the picks, I'd pass.

[Goddard]

With Mixon, that was an absolute steal. With just the picks, I'd pass.

Same here.

[lukkynumber13]

I think Mixon will likely finish with a better career straight up, so I'd easily take him and the picks

[RB6]

Pass on the revised offer. The Mixon deal was great.