Hyde for Jimmy G- single QB league

[UsualSuspects]

Something would need to be added to the Jimmy G side right? For my team in the signature.

[RB6]

I'd need an early to mid 2nd added. And it seems like a really great idea trading for a 6th QB in a 1QB league!

[pierson242]

I'd need an early to mid 2nd added. And it seems like a really great idea trading for a 6th QB in a 1QB league!

Lol yea no way I'm trading Hyde for a back up back up back up QB

[jwb32]

An early second would need to be added to Jimmy G side. Not sure why you'd even consider this trade though.

[bjd5211]

No need to roster Dobbs/Foles in this format, even Dalton is close to cutable. You don't need a QB, especially at the price of Hyde.

[hockeyBjj]

I'd need pretty much Hyde's straight value added to the Jimmy side in a 1QB league

[bjd5211]

Package Hyde/Dez for a WR upgrade, if your heart is really set on getting Jimmy G you should be able to get him + a nice receiver.

[UsualSuspects]

No need to roster Dobbs/Foles in this format, even Dalton is close to cutable. You don't need a QB, especially at the price of Hyde.

Foles was added after Wentz went down to block my playoff opponent from picking him up (he had to pick up Petty)

Dobbs was added after the season in case Big Ben retired since we drop our D's every year and I had 2 extra spots.

Dalton scares me which just leaves me Brady and Cousins (who is moving). I know that I value QBs higher than most on this forum but I always like to have 3 solid top Qbs. I think that all of you that run with a top starter and some middle of the pack backup on your team are crazy fwiw.

[pierson242]

No need to roster Dobbs/Foles in this format, even Dalton is close to cutable. You don't need a QB, especially at the price of Hyde.

Foles was added after Wentz went down to block my playoff opponent from picking him up (he had to pick up Petty)

Dobbs was added after the season in case Big Ben retired since we drop our D's every year and I had 2 extra spots.

Dalton scares me which just leaves me Brady and Cousins (who is moving). I know that I value QBs higher than most on this forum but I always like to have 3 solid top Qbs. I think that all of you that run with a top starter and some middle of the pack backup on your team are crazy fwiw.

Youd be crazier to run two top rbs and then have some middle of the back up rbs

[LondonMonarchs]

I'd need pretty much Hyde's straight value added to the Jimmy side in a 1QB league

X2

[Goddard]

Like others have already said, this trade just doesn't make sense for your team, even if you get fair value. With that said, I'd need a late 1st on top of Jimmy.

[saw061600]

No need to roster Dobbs/Foles in this format, even Dalton is close to cutable. You don't need a QB, especially at the price of Hyde.

Foles was added after Wentz went down to block my playoff opponent from picking him up (he had to pick up Petty)

Dobbs was added after the season in case Big Ben retired since we drop our D's every year and I had 2 extra spots.

Dalton scares me which just leaves me Brady and Cousins (who is moving). I know that I value QBs higher than most on this forum but I always like to have 3 solid top Qbs. I think that all of you that run with a top starter and some middle of the pack backup on your team are crazy fwiw.

Your leaguemates know this too which is why they're making you this offer. I get the Dobbs pickup and I wouldn't be quick to dump Foles (he's going to end up somewhere and likely starting after the last few weeks; plenty of desperate for a QB teams out there). You should be looking to speculatively trade both, get someone in need to buy. But your valuations of positions in your league format are completely, to use your word, crazy if you think Hyde equals JG.

[skip]

You can start Hyde. You will never start Garoppolo with your current QBs. The trade makes no sense for your team at all.

[ddog2303]

Piling on here. This trade doesn’t make any sense. With Cousins and Dalton behind Brady there is no reason to sacrifice RB depth for Jimmy G.