Gallman, Hill, or Montgomery

[Guru Master]

Who would you rather stash for the upside for 2018?

Thanks!

Guru Master

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

The guy in a top-5 offense with a future HoF QB...so Gallman

[Bot101]

Ty easily

[hockeyBjj]

I'm not huge on TY, but hands down TY has the best chance to produce fantasy relevant numbers

So worried about him being firmly replaced by a true running back though, a new GM that actually goes after free agents increases that chance

But if they don't bring anyone in, TY is good to own in PPR for another year

[Goddard]

Monty is the most talented player from that list.

[skip]

I'll be in the minority and go with Hill. I don't like Montgomery as anything more than a 3rd down back while Hill is more of a thumper and TD threat. He definitely comes with plenty of risk as he doesn't really have a job yet. But a team like the Jets make a ton of sense for him. He'd walk in and instantly be the starter for a team like that.

[pierson242]

I'll be in the minority and go with Hill. I don't like Montgomery as anything more than a 3rd down back while Hill is more of a thumper and TD threat. He definitely comes with plenty of risk as he doesn't really have a job yet. But a team like the Jets make a ton of sense for him. He'd walk in and instantly be the starter for a team like that.

I agree. I also voted Hill. TY isnt a Rb, hes a WR, i see him going back to wr and being lost with Adams Jordy and Cobb there. Hill always has the TD upside and he has flashed before.

[jpusmc0311]

I think Gallman is next to worthless... Darkwa is more talented and I still don't think they are comiitted to either of them two in NY. Montgomery is in a really crowded backfield with 2 legit RBs in Jones and Williams. Hill is still just 25 (26 by the start of next season) and has all the tools of being a stud RB. If he lands on a team that knows how to utilize him, he'll go back to being a RB 1/2

[jeaton6]

Ty. Hill hasn’t performed for 2 years. Cats out of the bag with that guy.

[Clem0423]

It's Monty not even a question. Hill is gone and will not land a lead back job, I would be suprised if he is on a week 1 active roster to be honest. The giants have no fantasy viable option at rb so skip them. Monty is safe because if he isn't the lead back he can flip to wr and play slot Adams is their number 1 but both Cobb and Nelson are cut candidates with their current contracts and recent production. Monty could be the lead back or number 2 wr in gb next year either way he has a role in an offense with Rodgers at qb.

[RB6]

Ty.

[skiptomybru]

It's Monty not even a question. Hill is gone and will not land a lead back job, I would be suprised if he is on a week 1 active roster to be honest. The giants have no fantasy viable option at rb so skip them. Monty is safe because if he isn't the lead back he can flip to wr and play slot Adams is their number 1 but both Cobb and Nelson are cut candidates with their current contracts and recent production. Monty could be the lead back or number 2 wr in gb next year either way he has a role in an offense with Rodgers at qb.

^ Yes. I am a Monty owner as well, and I really don't worry about much of a production drop off with Jones and Williams. He is versatile enough to switch out to WR, or take on the 3rd down back roll. GBP finds ways to get him his touches.

[thomasscheeks]

I'll be in the minority and go with Hill. I don't like Montgomery as anything more than a 3rd down back while Hill is more of a thumper and TD threat. He definitely comes with plenty of risk as he doesn't really have a job yet. But a team like the Jets make a ton of sense for him. He'd walk in and instantly be the starter for a team like that.

I agree Hill still has value, but I wouldn't be able to keep him over Monty. Monty will likely be the third down back, so that sucks. But he'll be the third down back on a team with Aaron Rodgers. lol. He should see plenty of opportunity. Safer bet than hoping Hill can salvage his career.

[i11inoisdbomfb]

Since the question is who would you rather stash I'll go with Hill.

He's gone from Cincy so a change of scenery may be what he needs.

Prior to 2017 he had rushing TD seasons of 9, 11, 9.

[Phaded]

I'll be in the minority and go with Hill. I don't like Montgomery as anything more than a 3rd down back while Hill is more of a thumper and TD threat. He definitely comes with plenty of risk as he doesn't really have a job yet. But a team like the Jets make a ton of sense for him. He'd walk in and instantly be the starter for a team like that.

I'm actually right there with skip. Of these 3; I would rather stash Jeremy Hill.
He has not looked fantastic as a Cincy runner recently; but nobody has. A change of scenery could be exactly the resurgence he needs to be a viable RB2-RB3.

Gallman is close to wire fodder is my eyes.

Not a believer in Ty; plus with both Jamaal Williams & Aaron Jones showing to be capable backs in an offense that will see most of their touchdowns come from Aaron Rodgers - not sure I really want any part of that. With two actual running backs on the team now, I can't see Ty emerging as the better one between the three.