Allen Robinson value for picks or players

[skiptomybru]

I have had an interest in Amari Cooper, but would have to give something back. Allen Robinson is really the only player I'd consider moving, but I'm also on the side that believes he will bounce back in a big way in 2018. Is Cooper worth looking into? Also, where would you put A Rob's value in terms of picks or players going into this off season? Thanks

[Favrezilla]

i think they are about equal in my opinion...ARob has outperformed Cooper (that one time...); at this point i feel like they are crossing (cooper decreasing and ARob increasing in value) ARob is also a FA and i cant imagine that JAX pays him a ton of money when they also have a couple other guys that have done fine in his absence, not great but they need other areas if they want to be a true contender imo.

i can see either side of this seeing it as equal (maybe less on the cooper side) but he has done little at this point aside from his draft pedigree as the 1.1 in many drafts.

[FantasyFreakGuru]

Its tough to say where A Rob value is... Hes never caught more then 80 balls in a season and had really one good year out of his 4 year career. Some of that is due to QB play. I would value him as a late first rounder. As for players I think hes in the same boat at Edelman, Cooper Kupp, Watkins?, and a degressing Jordy (alot of people are still high on him, I'm not.)

[Goddard]

Arob and Cooper should be valued pretty closely. As far as Arob's value in picks, I'd probably say he's worth around the 1.02.

[Vcize]

ARob seems like a bit of a hold to me until FA resolves. What are the chances he's catching balls from Bortles next year? Seems likely he'll either land somewhere else or Jacksonville will bring in a decent QB.

Just guessing I would say the most likely QBs he's catching passes from next year are Garoppolo, Trubisky, Cousins, or Eli. Only Trubisky from that group wouldn't be a massive improvement.

[Jak]

I would give Copper the nod over Robinson. But both are very close for me. I'd put both around the 1.4 - 1.6 range

[skiptomybru]

Thanks guys. I guess I'll let the off season settle in here, and reevaluate closer to the draft. Seems like if it's that close, it would probably be best to just ride it out with A Rob. That's what I've been leaning towards.

[SpartyOn]

I think both players are a hold right now and this just comes down to personal preference for an owner. I prefer ARob over Cooper. However, ARob could have a nice value spike in the coming months if he lands if a favorable spot via FA.

[thomasscheeks]

This is as lateral as trades come.

What's the point of trading a risky, high upside WR for an equally risky, high upside WR? It's impossible to tell which one, if any, bounce back in a big way. Just hold onto ARob and hope he has a nice season

[Phaded]

I would much rather have ARob than Cooper.
Value-wise the community will probably view them as close, though.

[Easy Breesy]

I would take AROB over cooper only because he has a chance to sign in a better and more consistent offence.

[FantasyFreakGuru]

AROB or Cooper now?

[The.Big.Spank]

You should add revisited to the post. I read about 8 of them before I realized this was a year old post.

I liked Cooper better then and like him even better than Arob now. I have never viewed Cooper as a downfield threat so pairing him with a qb like Stafford would be awful, but I do love his short game, finding seams and creases and YAC. To me this makes Dak the best type of qb to pair him with, especially since Zeke will keep 8 in the box a lot.

[The.Big.Spank]

Oh, and if you "A" is Auburn, feel free to beat bama once in a while.

[Jigga94]

Oh, and if you "A" is Auburn, feel free to beat bama once in a while.

That's Arizona