Micheal Thomas or Derrick Henry++

[freddog97]

I’m having trouble with an offer I received. I have decent WR depth that is underperforming and limited RBs but who doesn’t like adding a top flight WR!

I’m also in the playoffs.

12 team PPR
Start: QB 2RB 3WR TE Flex K D

I give:
Derrick Henry
Corey Coleman
2017 2.06

I get:
Micheal Thomas (NO)
Jax defense (currently ranked 15th in WR scoring lol)-172 points

My team:
QB Dalton

RBs Gurley Hunt Henry D.Foreman Crowell Woodhead

WRs B.Cooks Keenan Diggs Alshon CoColeman D.Parker D.Moncrief

TEs H.Henry OJ.Howard ASJ
Picks I own: 2.02 2.06 2nd(TBD)

[MontrealBen]

I'd do it. You're probably selling Henry in a window that's a few months short of his peak value (once Murray leaves everyone should be selling HARD, because someone in your league will value him insanely high). But, when you can turn three speculative assets into a top 10 WR and a D/ST that (no joke) could single handedly win you the championship, I think you do it.

[HughHoney]

Snap accept for me. Thomas side easily.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

I am a big Henry fan long-term, but I would make that trade. Jacksonville is worth the 2nd to a playoff team. In a best-case scenario, Henry will be worth similar to Thomas next year, but I would pay Coleman to guarantee getting that level player.

[pierson242]

Snap accept for me. Thomas side easily.

x2

[sloth8u]

Seems like a cheap buy on Thomas imo. Very speculative trade on the other owners part. What if Henry and Coleman amount to nothing??? Think you have to take the sure thing and I like Henry and coco

[dazza]

I'd do it too. JAX pushes it over the top for me (I know predicting future DEF production is crazy, but I like how they're set up for the next few years)

I will say I think Henry has shown enough that the only speculation involved is when he get the nod over Murray and exactly how high his ceiling is, but the Titans are strangely stubborn making the change. RB is the deep spot in the draft this year, though, and your WRs will be deep enough to flip one for a RB/QB later if you need to

[CurtisMyFavMartin]

I like the Thomas side by a wide margin too- but the other owner may be worried about Brees retiring in which case Thomas’ value may drop considerably.

Either way, I’d still take the deal.

Btw, you’re allowed to trade during the playoffs?

[RB6]

Thomas side.

[Triton85]

Extremely Cheap for Thomas... I'd take it in a heartbeat

You can ship out Alshon or Diggs for a older RB to hold you over

[freddog97]

I like the Thomas side by a wide margin too- but the other owner may be worried about Brees retiring in which case Thomas’ value may drop considerably.

Either way, I’d still take the deal.

Btw, you’re allowed to trade during the playoffs?

I ended up taking the deal.

And yes trading is allowed !

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I ended up taking the deal.

Big win. Should help you immensely in the playoffs.

[npainter]

Definitely Thomas.

[Goddard]

That's a steal.

[cptjonesb]

Thomas side