Sitting On 2 Offers. Need Help (Poll)

[psfox2010]

This is for the team in the below signature. I'm one of the top 3 teams and contending. Deadline is today at noon. I've received the below offers...

Offer 1
Give: Jordan Howard/2018 1st (late)
Get: Dalvin Cook

Offer 2
Give: Green/Howard/Collins/Morris/2 2018 1sts (both late)
Get: Hopkins/Mixon/Foreman/2018 3rd (early)

Which do you all prefer or would you just stay put? Any help is appreciated.

[dazza]

I like #1. Solid deal to get a 3-down back in ppr, and you should be able to cover Howard's loss during your run this year

#2 I'm more torn on. Take a first out and I think it's fair, but as a contender you're probably hurting your run this year (and I'm assuming making another contender stronger?)

[skip]

Neither for me. Howard for Cook straight up, maybe, no way the gap is a first round pick - particularly since you have the healthy RB.

As to the second deal, the 1sts also make it an overpay. Green/Howard or Hopkins/Mixon is close to a push. The rest of the deal you are giving up far too much.

[MontrealBen]

If you're contending, you can't do trade #1. That should be there in the offseason. As for trade #2, that doesn't help you this year, or down the road. Easy pass.

[Suhmdog]

Neither is a slam dunk. I'd sit pat

[vixen]

i may be too late, but i would not make either trade

[BelichekYourSelf]

Neither for me. Howard for Cook straight up, maybe, no way the gap is a first round pick - particularly since you have the healthy RB.

As to the second deal, the 1sts also make it an overpay. Green/Howard or Hopkins/Mixon is close to a push. The rest of the deal you are giving up far too much.

I agree with this.

[Trevormortis]

Neither. I have Howard>Cook slightly. Option 2 is even worse.

[Goddard]

I like the second offer if those 1sts are both late.

[psfox2010]

Looks like I went complcompletely against the consensus and took offer #2. The 2 1sts are late, possibly the last 2 picks, and I couldn't pass on the opportunity to have Hopkins. To me the key pieces were Nuk/Mixon and Green/Howard. I might be in the minority, but I prefer both Hopkins and Mixon over the other two. It's all a gamble regardless of the side you prefer. Either way, thanks for all the great feedback as always.

[block2323]

I do not mind offer 2 but you shouldn't need to give up 2 firsts. Unfortunately these trades do not help you this year. I understand why you could want Hopkins however. Hopefully this doesn't hurt your chances of winning it all.

[hockeyBjj]

Definitely not the 1st one. Maybe the second one for Hopkins. Maybe

[iceman68]

Stay pat, unless you can change the 1st with Howard to a lower pick for Cook.

[jeaton6]

Yowsas bad overpay imo. Mixon hasn't flashed at all with lots of opportunity. No idea why anyone would view him equal to Howard. I think you need to drop Collins and a 2018 1 to make it close to equal

[BigBawseRoss]

deal 1 is ok...dont like deal 2