Arob vs Kamara

[thebeast]

16 team ppr

Contender sends Arob

Rebuild sends Kamar and Watkins

Who wins?

[seachicken206]

May as well contend and go with kamara and watkins. Plus i think its a good trade without contending.

[smoppelpoppel]

Would keep Kamara and Watkins in a rebuild. Kamara might be the lead guy in NO backfield next year (and is already doing well), Watkins will bounce back, too much talent there. Not sure if ARob comes back.

[Rasorin]

I would not do this trade. Kamara could be the best rookie this year and is currently undervalued IMO. His ceiling is LBell. Watkins is definitely undervalued and you don't know where he or ARob will be next year. Contending or rebuilding I prefer the Watkins/Kamara side.

[Phaded]

I like the Kamara & Watkins side.

Back on October 19 (before Kamara "exploded"), I did a 4-for-4 deal where I sent ARob+ for Kamara+.

I don't regret it.

[topher]

No way you would need to give both, I would do Watkins straight up, prolly not Kamara

[AlPal&Ange]

I'd take the Kamara side super easily. However, I do think that Arob is better than Watkins. Not sold on him and Goff looks good but is throwing the ball to less talented receivers... I know it's a new team for Sammy but its not week 5 anymore there should be more chemistry.

[Kramer]

Has Watkins' value fell so much that he's not even mentioned in the title?

ARob vs Watkins could be a good discussion on its own still. Plenty of supporters of both players. Both just need better situations where their talents are used properly. Regardless of where you stand on that, Kamara pushes it way over to that side.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

Kamara is the most valuable piece, IMO. Watkins and ARob are about equal. Both good rebuilding assets and awful contending assets.

[J. Edgar]

Kamara and Watkins by quite a bit, if I was receiving them it would be a huge win imo.

[dazza]

Easily Kamara/Watkins. Easily Kamara alone, and probably Watkins alone (don't forget he's also a FA after this year if that chemistry doesn't happen with Goff)

[Goddard]

This title is pretty misleading. Arob and Kamara should be close. Watkins is more than just a throw-in.

[hankmurphy]

No way I would give up Kamara for ARob straight up, and definitely not throwing in Watkins on top.

Kamara is a rookie, so I would imagine he's much more valuable for a rebuilding team than a 4th year WR with an injury history and only one great season under his belt.

[wildabeast49]

piling on, not close

[Samhain34]

This trade is crazy talk from the rebuilding side. Nobody knows who is going to be the QB for JAX next year, and they're hell-bent on running it anyway. Add that to the fact that Lee is looking legit and you would be crazy to trade Kamara away for ARob straight up, much less adding Watkins.