Stephon Diggs or Tyreek Hill *poll*

[darkadun]

Prefer Diggs too. But it’s close simply due to Diggs injury history so I can see going with Hill.

[Bot101]

Prefer Diggs too. But it’s close simply due to Diggs injury history so I can see going with Hill.

Hi leaguemate

[hjernazian]

Surprised at the disparity in responses. It's Diggs - and it's not even close for me. He has giant upside, Teddy is on his way back, and the knocks on him for Theilen don't make sense as they are entirely different type of WRs. Can Jordy Nelson and D. Adams not co-exist? Also, I really don't like Hill so I have to be transparent about that - as an athlete and as a person even less.

[lukkynumber13]

Surprised at the disparity in responses. It's Diggs - and it's not even close for me. He has giant upside, Teddy is on his way back, and the knocks on him for Theilen don't make sense as they are entirely different type of WRs. Can Jordy Nelson and D. Adams not co-exist? Also, I really don't like Hill so I have to be transparent about that - as an athlete and as a person even less.

I agree that it's Diggs for sure IMO, but I have to pick a bone on one of your points:

"Teddy is on his way back"

Why on earth would Bridgewater be a benefit to his WRs? Especially given the fact that Keenum is a gunslinger. Teddy might be the better NFL player, but Keenum is the better QB for fantasy.

[hjernazian]

Surprised at the disparity in responses. It's Diggs - and it's not even close for me. He has giant upside, Teddy is on his way back, and the knocks on him for Theilen don't make sense as they are entirely different type of WRs. Can Jordy Nelson and D. Adams not co-exist? Also, I really don't like Hill so I have to be transparent about that - as an athlete and as a person even less.

I agree that it's Diggs for sure IMO, but I have to pick a bone on one of your points:

"Teddy is on his way back"

Why on earth would Bridgewater be a benefit to his WRs? Especially given the fact that Keenum is a gunslinger. Teddy might be the better NFL player, but Keenum is the better QB for fantasy.

You are right. But if we break it down, IMO he is the better QB. That's where the foundation of my logic lies. But again, excellent point about Keenum being a gunslinger, only benefits Diggs' game.

[Samhain34]

Does the QB situation for either team in 2018 move the needle at all?

They shouldn't. Both are total unknowns.

This.

Another thing is that both Diggs (and Thielen) have been making Keenum look good; if they ever get a capable QB back there, watch out. Also, the emergence of Thielen is going to help Diggs. I like Hill as a player, but I give the edge to Diggs, who is reeling in almost 70% of his contested catches, which is absurd.

[BigBawseRoss]

When healthy I would give the edge to Diggs.

When healthy, I think Diggs is a top 8 WR in fantasy. Its Diggs and not close over Hill, IMO (if health wasn't a concern)

That's why I give him the edge over Hill even considering Diggs' soft tissue history.

Hill currently IS healthy and IS a top 8 WR...top 5 i believe (all my leagues are 0.5 ppr)

[mike40]

As an owner of both I take Diggs. I think he has both a higher floor and ceiling week to week as long as he's healthy. I'm in a full point ppr and even with the 3 games he has missed (including the game he got hurt) he is still the #22 WR in my league. Just make sure you have a good #4WR for the games he's going to miss.

[dblj1199]

Pretty much on board with most others, Diggs and it would be a much wider margin if he weren't always banged up.

[MockGM]

I own both and will kind of go against the grain here. It all depends on the format, for PPR I'd probably lean slightly to Diggs, for standard I'd take Hill all day and feel he has the higher upside.

This is completely subjective, but the eye test for me says Hill. The way he moves around the field, his speed and how effortlessly he can blow past other pros looks to be a generational talent.

[lic217]

I take Diggs pretty easily.

[topher]

Diggs for me, would prefer the pure talent and the injuries are not concerning enough for me.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Does the QB situation for either team in 2018 move the needle at all?

They shouldn't. Both are total unknowns.

Not really...a lot is up in the air with MIN's QB situation, but KC will 95% likely be starting Smith or Mahomes...I'll take Hill here. The man is TY Hilton lite, so I'll take that over Antonio Brown lite with recurring groin injuries.

[lukkynumber13]

Does the QB situation for either team in 2018 move the needle at all?

They shouldn't. Both are total unknowns.

Not really...a lot is up in the air with MIN's QB situation, but KC will 95% likely be starting Smith or Mahomes...I'll take Hill here. The man is TY Hilton lite, so I'll take that over Antonio Brown lite with recurring groin injuries.

So you're saying there's a 5% chance a 3rd QB enters into the conversation, via injuries or something

Out of the 95%, there's probably a 50% chance Smith is the starter

So that means there's a 45% chance Mahomes is the guy there next year. And we do NOT know what he will be. Anyone that thinks he's a known asset is a fool. He is a guy that's pure projection

So yes, I'd say there are a lot of unknowns when it comes to the KC quarterback room

[Ghosted]

It's Diggs, man. He's one of the most underrated route-runners in the league. Creates major separation at all 3 levels, and has a higher-than-league-average catch rate at literally every level of depth-of-target. He's the closest thing to Antonio Brown that we have. Hill in nice too, but I view his route acumen as being a slightly bigger concern than Diggs' injury history, personally.